Luciani L, Coccarelli F, Pusiol T, Piscioli F
Service d'Urologie, Centre Hospitalier S. Chiara, Trento, Italie.
J Urol (Paris). 1988;94(2):87-9.
Accuracy of staging of prostatic cancer is related to invasive procedures since imaging methods do not allow a reliable knowledge of the nodal status. Unfortunately lymphadenectomy is adversely affected by morbidity and mortality, therefore alternative methods should be elaborated. Post-lymphographic aspiration cytology seems to be worthwhile, having proved to be a reliable, accurate, safe procedure which can provide useful information in the management of patients with prostatic cancer. Nevertheless uncertainty exists upon the clinical significance of negative cytologic findings. In this connection correlation between grading and aspiration cytology can constitute a further improvement. In our experience the Gleason grading system has shown to be the most reliable and reproducible. 85 patients classified according to the Gleason's system, underwent staging lymphadenectomy and no nodal metastases were present when the Gleason score was lower than 5. In 50 cases even aspiration cytology was accomplished before surgery. No false positive cytologic findings were seen on histologic verification. Two false negative results were obtained in patients with Gleason score higher than 5. In conclusion we believe that when prostatic cancer shows a Gleason score lower than 5 and the lymph node aspiration cytology is negative no staging lymphadenectomy should be performed. On the contrary in cases with Gleason sum from 5 to 10 negative nodal cytologic findings are inconclusive, nevertheless this rate of patients is low and the necessity of surgical staging can be really reduced.
前列腺癌分期的准确性与侵入性操作相关,因为影像学方法无法可靠地了解淋巴结状态。不幸的是,淋巴结切除术受到发病率和死亡率的不利影响,因此应制定替代方法。淋巴造影后细针穿刺活检似乎是值得的,已被证明是一种可靠、准确、安全的方法,可为前列腺癌患者的管理提供有用信息。然而,阴性细胞学结果的临床意义仍存在不确定性。在这方面,分级与细针穿刺活检之间的相关性可能会进一步改善。根据我们的经验,Gleason分级系统已被证明是最可靠且可重复的。85例根据Gleason系统分类的患者接受了分期淋巴结切除术,当Gleason评分低于5时未发现淋巴结转移。在50例病例中,术前还进行了细针穿刺活检。组织学验证未发现假阳性细胞学结果。Gleason评分高于5的患者中有2例出现假阴性结果。总之,我们认为,当前列腺癌的Gleason评分低于5且淋巴结细针穿刺活检为阴性时,不应进行分期淋巴结切除术。相反,在Gleason总和为5至10的病例中,阴性淋巴结细胞学结果尚无定论,不过这类患者的比例较低,手术分期的必要性可真正降低。