McMillan Ryan A, Bowen Andrew J, Wells Michael L, Ekbom Dale C
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 2022 Feb;131(2):117-125. doi: 10.1177/00034894211012589. Epub 2021 Apr 30.
Transoral endoscopic laser-assisted diverticulotomy (TELD) with diverticulectomy and diverticuloplasty (TELD + DD) for the management of Zenker's diverticulum (ZD) has been utilized by our institution since 2016 in attempts to reduce residual pouch size. This technique involves complete endoscopic pouch excision with partial advancement of mucosal flaps. Our study compares the subjective outcomes, objective outcomes, and complication rates between TELD and TELD + DD.
A retrospective cohort study was performed on patients who underwent TELD or TELD + DD by a single surgeon at a tertiary academic center (2013-2019). Videofluoroscopic swallow studies (VFSS) with esophagram, Eating Assessment Tool (EAT-10), Reflux Symptom Index (RSI), and Functional Outcome Swallowing Scale (FOSS) were collected at preoperative and 3 month follow-up visits. A single blinded reviewer recorded height, width, and depth of pre and postoperative pouches with volumetric analysis performed assuming an ellipsoid shape. Comorbidities, complications, postoperative course, and recurrence were recorded.
Of the 75 patients that met criteria, 27 underwent TELD + DD and 48 underwent TELD. Eighteen TELD + DD and 37 TELD had both pre and post-operative VFSS. TELD + DD and TELD had a 96 ± 7% and 87 ± 16% reduction in pouch volume, respectively (-test; = .01). Complications (TELD + DD 7%, TELD 17%, fisher's exact; = .31) and final subjective outcomes after adjusting for initial were not significantly different between methods (EAT-10 with TELD + DD ∆ + 1.3, = .18; RSI ∆ + 1.4, = .29; FOSS ∆-0.02, = .91). One short-term recurrence was reported with TELD.
Use of TELD + DD is associated with a statistically significantly decreased residual pouch size with no significant difference in short-term subjective outcomes. Complication rates and short-term recurrence rates are comparable. Long-term recurrence rates will require further studies to characterize.
Level 3.
自2016年以来,我们机构采用经口内镜激光辅助憩室切开术(TELD)联合憩室切除术和憩室成形术(TELD+DD)来治疗Zenker憩室(ZD),旨在减小残余憩室的大小。该技术包括在内镜下完整切除憩室并部分推进黏膜瓣。我们的研究比较了TELD与TELD+DD在主观结果、客观结果及并发症发生率方面的差异。
对在一家三级学术中心由同一外科医生实施TELD或TELD+DD手术的患者进行回顾性队列研究(2013 - 2019年)。在术前及术后3个月随访时收集食管造影的视频荧光吞咽造影检查(VFSS)、饮食评估工具(EAT - 10)、反流症状指数(RSI)及功能性吞咽结局量表(FOSS)。由一名单盲评审员记录术前和术后憩室的高度、宽度及深度,并假设其为椭球形进行容积分析。记录合并症、并发症、术后病程及复发情况。
在符合标准的75例患者中,27例行TELD+DD,48例行TELD。18例TELD+DD和37例TELD患者术前行了VFSS检查且术后也进行了复查。TELD+DD组和TELD组的憩室容积分别减少了96±7%和87±16%(t检验;P = 0.01)。并发症发生率(TELD+DD组7%,TELD组17%,Fisher精确检验;P = 0.31),并且在对初始情况进行校正后,两种方法的最终主观结果无显著差异(TELD+DD组EAT - 10改善+1.3,P = 0.18;RSI改善+1.4,P = 0.29;FOSS改善 - 0.02,P = 0.91)。TELD组报告有1例短期复发。
使用TELD+DD与残余憩室大小在统计学上显著减小相关,短期主观结果无显著差异。并发症发生率和短期复发率相当。长期复发率需要进一步研究来确定。
3级。