Bainbridge R R, Mimouni F, Tsang R C
Department of Pediatrics, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, OH 45267-0541.
J Pediatr. 1988 Jul;113(1 Pt 2):205-7. doi: 10.1016/s0022-3476(88)80612-7.
We compared the results of two studies that measured the bone mineral content (BMC) of 57 infants fed soy-based formula and 27 infants fed human milk or cow milk-based formula at various ages from 2 weeks to 1 year. In a study by Chan et al., the BMC of 40 white infants fed soy-based formula and 10 infants (of unstated race) fed human milk was measured at 2 weeks and at 2 and 4 months of age. The infants fed soy-based formula also had BMC measured at 6 and 12 months; the BMC of these infants was compared to the BMC of human milk-fed historical control subjects. The BMC was similar at 2 weeks in both groups but was lower in infants fed soy-based formula than in human milk-fed infants at 2 and 4 months. The BMC was similar in historical control subjects fed human milk and in soy formula-fed infants at 6 and 12 months. In the Steichen-Tsang study, the BMC of 17 soy formula-fed infants and of 17 white infants fed cow milk-based formula was measured at 6 weeks and at 3, 6, and 12 months of age. The BMC was similar at 6 weeks in both groups but was lower in infants fed soy-based formula than in those fed cow milk-based formula at 3, 6, and 12 months. The BMC of the historical control group fed human milk and of the soy formula-fed infants was also similar. In the first year of life, the BMC of infants fed soy formula and those fed human milk appears to be similar, especially after 6 months of age. However, the BMC of infants so fed may be lower than that of infants fed cow milk-based formula.
我们比较了两项研究的结果,这两项研究测量了57名食用大豆配方奶粉的婴儿和27名食用母乳或牛奶配方奶粉的婴儿在2周龄至1岁不同年龄段的骨矿物质含量(BMC)。在Chan等人的一项研究中,测量了40名食用大豆配方奶粉的白人婴儿和10名(未说明种族)食用母乳的婴儿在2周龄、2个月龄和4个月龄时的BMC。食用大豆配方奶粉的婴儿在6个月龄和12个月龄时也测量了BMC;这些婴儿的BMC与食用母乳的历史对照受试者的BMC进行了比较。两组在2周龄时BMC相似,但在2个月龄和4个月龄时,食用大豆配方奶粉的婴儿的BMC低于食用母乳的婴儿。在6个月龄和12个月龄时,食用母乳的历史对照受试者和食用大豆配方奶粉的婴儿的BMC相似。在Steichen - Tsang的研究中,测量了17名食用大豆配方奶粉的婴儿和17名食用牛奶配方奶粉的白人婴儿在6周龄、3个月龄、6个月龄和12个月龄时的BMC。两组在6周龄时BMC相似,但在3个月龄、6个月龄和12个月龄时,食用大豆配方奶粉的婴儿的BMC低于食用牛奶配方奶粉的婴儿。食用母乳的历史对照组和食用大豆配方奶粉的婴儿的BMC也相似。在生命的第一年,食用大豆配方奶粉的婴儿和食用母乳的婴儿的BMC似乎相似,尤其是在6个月龄之后。然而,如此喂养的婴儿的BMC可能低于食用牛奶配方奶粉的婴儿。