Giordano Vincenzo, Lyra Juliana, Bonadiman João Artur, Lech Osvandré
Serviço de Ortopedia e Traumatologia Prof. Nova Monteiro, Hospital Municipal Miguel Couto, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Clínica São Vicente, Rede D'or São Luiz, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Rev Bras Ortop (Sao Paulo). 2021 Apr;56(2):154-160. doi: 10.1055/s-0041-1728702. Epub 2021 Apr 26.
To outline the profile of self-citations from Revista Brasileira de Ortopedia (Rev Bras Ortop) and citations of this journal in other medical orthopaedic journals with general or specific content in a knowledge area of the specialty. This is an observational cross-sectional study of the frequency of self-citations and citations from Rev Bras Ortop in five other medical orthopaedic journals from different countries, all published in English. The last 15 articles published in 2020 in each of the six journals were analyzed. The references used in each of them were evaluated to identify the journal in which they were originally published. The frequency of distribution of the four main journals cited, their position, and the relative percentage to the total number of citations were observed and recorded in each of the six journals. The number of times that the Rev Bras Ortop was cited in each of the selected foreign journals was assessed using its absolute and relative frequencies. The total number of citations evaluated in this study was 2,527 (ranging from 386 to 486 per magazine). Rev Bras Ortop showed a low rate of self-citation (2.6%), being the sixth journal cited in the journal itself (10 out of a total of 386 references). Moreover, Rev Bras Ortop was not mentioned in any of the other five medical journals included in the study (absolute frequency 0, relative frequency 0). Rev Bras Ortop has a low reference of itself, with a self-citation rate of 2.6% in the studied period, showing that the Brazilian orthopaedic surgeons do not mention the Brazilian orthopaedic surgeon who publishes in the journal. We suggest the elaboration and implementation of strong strategies to improve the journal's visibility in the world academic-scientific scenario. In addition, it is essential that Brazilian orthopaedic surgeons understand this reality and assist directly and effectively to change this scenario.
概述《巴西骨科学杂志》(Rev Bras Ortop)的自引情况,以及该杂志在其他具有该专业知识领域一般或特定内容的医学骨科杂志中的被引情况。
这是一项观察性横断面研究,旨在研究《巴西骨科学杂志》的自引频率以及在其他五本来自不同国家、均以英文出版的医学骨科杂志中的被引频率。分析了这六本杂志在2020年发表的最后15篇文章。评估每篇文章中使用的参考文献,以确定其最初发表的杂志。观察并记录六本杂志中被引用的四种主要杂志的分布频率、排名及其在总引用次数中的相对百分比。使用绝对频率和相对频率评估所选外国杂志中引用《巴西骨科学杂志》的次数。
本研究评估的总引用次数为2527次(每本杂志从386次到486次不等)。《巴西骨科学杂志》的自引率较低(2.6%),在该杂志自身被引用的杂志中排名第六(在总共386条参考文献中有10条)。此外,本研究纳入的其他五本医学杂志均未提及《巴西骨科学杂志》(绝对频率为0,相对频率为0)。
《巴西骨科学杂志》的自引率较低,在研究期间自引率为2.6%,这表明巴西骨科医生未提及在该杂志上发表文章的巴西骨科医生。我们建议制定并实施强有力的策略,以提高该杂志在世界学术科学领域的知名度。此外,巴西骨科医生必须了解这一现实,并直接有效地协助改变这种局面。