Institute for Population Health, Weill Cornell Medicine-Qatar, Ar-Rayyan, Qatar.
Syst Rev. 2021 May 5;10(1):136. doi: 10.1186/s13643-021-01691-9.
In nursing students, high stress levels can lead to burnout, anxiety, and depression. Our objective is to characterize the epidemiology of perceived stress, stressors, and coping strategies among nursing students in the Middle East and North Africa region.
We conducted an overview of systematic reviews. We systematically searched PubMed, Embase, PsycInfo, and grey literature sources between January 2008 and June 2020 with no language restrictions. We included any systematic review reporting measurable stress-related outcomes including stress prevalence, stressors, and stress coping strategies in nursing students residing in any of the 20 Middle East and North Africa countries. We also included additional primary studies identified through a hand search of the reference lists of relevant primary studies and systematic reviews.
Seven systematic reviews and 42 primary studies with data from Bahrain, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Oman, Pakistan, Palestine, Saudi Arabia, and Sudan were identified. Most studies included nursing students undergoing clinical training. The prevalence range of low, moderate, and high perceived stress among nursing students was 0.8-65%, 5.9-84.5%, and 6.7-99.2%, respectively. Differences related to gender, training period, or the type of tool used to measure stress remain unclear given the wide variability in the reported prevalence measures across all stress levels. Common clinical training stressors were assignments, workload, and patient care. Academic training-related stressors included lack of break/leisure time, low grades, exams, and course load. Nursing students utilized problem focused (dealing with the problem), emotion focused (regulating the emotion), and dysfunctional (venting the emotions) stress coping mechanisms to alleviate their stress.
Available data does not allow the exploration of links between stress levels, stressors, and coping strategies. Limited country-specific prevalence data prevents comparability between countries. Reducing the number or intensity of stressors through curriculum revision and improving students' coping response could contribute to the reduction of stress levels among students. Mentorship, counseling, and an environment conducive to clinical training are essential to minimize perceived stress, enhance learning, and productivity, and prevent burnout among nursing students.
在护理学生中,高压力水平可能导致倦怠、焦虑和抑郁。我们的目标是描述中东和北非地区护理学生感知压力、压力源和应对策略的流行病学特征。
我们进行了系统综述概述。我们系统地检索了 PubMed、Embase、PsycInfo 和灰色文献资源,检索时间为 2008 年 1 月至 2020 年 6 月,无语言限制。我们纳入了任何报告可衡量的与压力相关结局的系统综述,包括居住在 20 个中东和北非国家中的护理学生的压力流行率、压力源和压力应对策略。我们还通过对相关原始研究和系统综述的参考文献进行手动搜索,纳入了额外的原始研究。
确定了 7 篇系统综述和 42 项原始研究,这些研究的数据来自巴林、埃及、伊拉克、约旦、阿曼、巴基斯坦、巴勒斯坦、沙特阿拉伯和苏丹。大多数研究纳入了正在接受临床培训的护理学生。护理学生中低度、中度和高度感知压力的流行率范围分别为 0.8%-65%、5.9%-84.5%和 6.7%-99.2%。鉴于所有压力水平的报告流行率测量值存在很大差异,性别、培训期或用于测量压力的工具类型方面的差异仍不清楚。常见的临床培训压力源包括任务、工作量和患者护理。与学术培训相关的压力源包括缺乏休息/闲暇时间、成绩低、考试和课程负担。护理学生利用问题焦点(处理问题)、情绪焦点(调节情绪)和功能失调(发泄情绪)的应对机制来减轻压力。
现有数据不允许探讨压力水平、压力源和应对策略之间的联系。有限的特定国家的流行率数据使得各国之间的可比性受到限制。通过课程修订减少压力源的数量或强度,并改善学生的应对反应,可能有助于降低学生的压力水平。指导、咨询以及有利于临床培训的环境对于最大限度地减少护理学生的感知压力、提高学习和工作效率以及预防倦怠至关重要。