International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA), C/o World Vegetable Centre-Eastern and Southern Africa, Arusha, Tanzania.
International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI), Washington, DC, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2021 May 6;16(5):e0250848. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0250848. eCollection 2021.
A relatively large body of literature has documented the welfare effects of smallholder farmers' participation in single-commodity output markets. However, limited empirical evidence is available when smallholder farmers participate in multiple-commodities output markets. We tried to fill this gap in the literature by estimating the impacts of smallholder farmers' contemporaneous participation in both maize and legume markets vis-à-vis in only maize or legume markets using household-level data from Tanzania. Applying a multinomial endogenous switching regression model that allows controlling for observed and unobserved heterogeneity associated with market participation in single-commodity and multiple-commodity markets, results showed that smallholder farmers' participation in both single-and multiple-commodity markets was positively and significantly associated with household income and food security. Moreover, the greatest benefits were obtained when farmers participated in multiple-commodity markets, suggesting the importance of policies promoting diversification in crop income sources to increase welfare and food security. Our findings also signal the complementary-rather than substitute-nature of accessing multiple-commodity markets for enhancing household livelihoods under a specialization strategy. Finally, important policy implications are suggested, from promoting and supporting public infrastructure investments to expanding road networks to reduce transportation costs, especially in remote communities, to enhance smallholder farmer access to profitable maize and legume markets in Tanzania.
大量文献记录了小农参与单一商品产出市场的福利效应。然而,当小农参与多种商品产出市场时,可用的经验证据有限。我们试图通过利用来自坦桑尼亚的家庭层面数据,在小农同时参与玉米和豆类市场与仅参与玉米或豆类市场的情况下,运用多元内生转换回归模型来填补这一文献空白,该模型允许控制与单一和多种商品市场参与相关的观察到和未观察到的异质性。结果表明,小农同时参与单一和多种商品市场与家庭收入和粮食安全呈正相关且显著相关。此外,当农民参与多种商品市场时,获得的收益最大,这表明促进作物收入来源多样化的政策对于提高福利和粮食安全非常重要。我们的研究结果还表明,在专业化战略下,获取多种商品市场对于提高家庭生计具有互补性,而不是替代性。最后,建议采取重要的政策措施,包括促进和支持公共基础设施投资,扩大道路网络以降低运输成本,特别是在偏远社区,以增强坦桑尼亚小农进入有利可图的玉米和豆类市场的机会。