Torres Ana Rita, Silva Susana, Kislaya Irina, Martins João Pedro, Matias Dias Carlos, Rodrigues Ana Paula
Departamento de Epidemiologia. Instituto Nacional de Saúde Doutor Ricardo Jorge. Lisboa. Portugal.
Departamento de Epidemiologia. Instituto Nacional de Saúde Doutor Ricardo Jorge. Lisboa. Centro de Investigação em Saúde Pública. Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública. Universidade NOVA de Lisboa. Lisboa. Comprehensive Health Research Center. Faculdade de Ciências Médicas de Lisboa. Lisboa. Portugal.
Acta Med Port. 2021 Mar 1;34(3):176-184. doi: 10.20344/amp.14593.
Syndromic surveillance allows early detection of changes in the population's morbidity pattern. The aim of this study is to evaluate the usefulness of indicators related to access to healthcare services, in COVID-19 surveillance.
A time series analysis was performed using the weekly incidence rate of COVID-19 in Mainland Portugal, between weeks 14/2020 (March 30 to April 5) and 25/2020 (June 15 to 21), and six indicators: 1) COVID-19 consultations in primary healthcare; 2) number of COVID-19 emergency department visits; 3) number of emergency department visits due to viral pneumonia; 4) number of hospitalizations due to viral pneumonia; 5) proportion of emergency department visits due to viral pneumonia; and 6) proportion of hospitalizations for viral pneumonia. Pearson correlation and cross-correlations were computed.
A strong correlation was found between the weekly incidence rate of COVID-19 and all indicators. [(1) 0.76; (2) 0.82; (3) 0.77; (4) 0.84; (5) 0.86; e (6) 0.90]. Emergency department visits and hospitalizations for viral pneumonia detect variations in the frequency of the disease with a one week lag compared to the incidence rate of COVID-19, in one week. COVID-19 consultations in primary healthcare and emergency department visits trail behind the incidence rate of COVID-19, in one week. The proportion of viral pneumonias in emergency department visits, or hospitalizations, is temporally aligned with the weekly incidence rate of COVID-19.
The delay found in the COVID-19 primary healthcare consultations and emergency department visits, may be related to changes in access to healthcare services and clinical coding. Emergency department visits and hospitalizations for viral pneumonia may be useful in the early detection of COVID-19. Viral pneumonia may have been coded as being of unknown origin. Future monitoring of these indicators is necessary to ascertain whether the incidence of COVID-19 is significantly influenced by changes in testing strategies. The indicators described in this study will be an asset for the optimization of testing strategies, allocation of healthcare resources to the communities that are most vulnerable to severe morbidity and assessing vaccination impact. As such, surveillance systems based on clinical data will be a valuable complementary tool to SINAVE.
The indicators under analysis could be used regularly, with special attention to viral pneumonias, to detect outbreaks of COVID-19. Information on pneumonia of unknown etiology may be considered in the surveillance of COVID-19.
症状监测有助于早期发现人群发病模式的变化。本研究的目的是评估与获得医疗服务相关的指标在新冠病毒疾病监测中的作用。
采用时间序列分析方法,分析了2020年第14周(3月30日至4月5日)至第25周(6月15日至21日)期间葡萄牙大陆新冠病毒疾病的每周发病率,并分析了六个指标:1)基层医疗保健机构的新冠病毒疾病咨询量;2)新冠病毒疾病急诊就诊人数;3)病毒性肺炎急诊就诊人数;4)病毒性肺炎住院人数;5)病毒性肺炎急诊就诊比例;6)病毒性肺炎住院比例。计算了Pearson相关性和交叉相关性。
发现新冠病毒疾病的每周发病率与所有指标之间均存在强相关性。[(1)0.76;(2)0.82;(3)0.77;(4)0.84;(5)0.86;(6)0.90]。与新冠病毒疾病发病率相比,病毒性肺炎急诊就诊和住院人数在一周后可检测到疾病频率的变化。基层医疗保健机构的新冠病毒疾病咨询量和急诊就诊人数比新冠病毒疾病发病率滞后一周。急诊就诊或住院中病毒性肺炎的比例与新冠病毒疾病的每周发病率在时间上一致。
新冠病毒疾病基层医疗保健咨询和急诊就诊中发现的延迟,可能与获得医疗服务的变化和临床编码有关。病毒性肺炎急诊就诊和住院人数可能有助于早期发现新冠病毒疾病。病毒性肺炎可能被编码为病因不明。未来有必要对这些指标进行监测,以确定新冠病毒疾病的发病率是否受到检测策略变化的显著影响。本研究中描述的指标将有助于优化检测策略、将医疗资源分配到最易发生严重发病的社区以及评估疫苗接种影响。因此,基于临床数据的监测系统将是国家疫情监测信息系统(SINAVE)的宝贵补充工具。
所分析的指标可定期使用,尤其要关注病毒性肺炎,以检测新冠病毒疾病的暴发。在新冠病毒疾病监测中可考虑病因不明的肺炎信息。