Morris Stephen, Smith Andrew, Lewin Cathy, Hick Peter, Harrison Jordan
Policy Evaluation and Research Unit, Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK.
Education and Social Research Institute, Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK.
Trials. 2021 May 10;22(1):333. doi: 10.1186/s13063-021-05280-y.
The trial will study the effects of the Whole School SEND Review on secondary school pupils in English mainstream education, to understand the impact of the intervention on academic attainment, wellbeing, and school attendance. The Review is designed to facilitate whole-school change through providing enhanced, intensive and sustained support and training in inclusive education for school special educational needs coordinators and leadership teams. The trial will have a specific focus on pupils designated as having special educational needs or disabilities.
We recruited 160 English secondary schools (approx. 58,000 pupils across two cohorts) to a two-arm pragmatic parallel cluster randomised controlled trial, with allocation at the school level. Randomisation will be stratified by school region. The primary outcome is attainment in English language (using standardised national test results at 16 years) for pupils designated as having a special educational need (approx. 4000 pupils). Secondary outcomes will be measured for pupils both with and without a special educational need designation and include pupil wellbeing (measured using the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire), absences and exclusions, and attainment in Mathematics and English language at 16 years. The intervention will be implemented from July 2021 and analysis of outcomes (for the year 9 cohort) will take place in September 2023, with further analysis (for the year 8 cohort) in September 2024 if the evaluation shows that acceptable implementation fidelity has been achieved.
Pupils with special educational needs represent a significant and often vulnerable part of the secondary school population, are disproportionately likely to be excluded from school, eligible for free school meals, or supported by children's social care. Despite these multiple important areas of need, school leaders report substantial challenges in making additional provision for this group. Previous research has highlighted the development of inclusive school cultures (rather focusing primarily on targeted individualised approaches) as being important. This trial will investigate how an intervention designed to drive whole school change may lead to outcomes for pupils with and without a special educational needs designation. As such, this trial is expected to make an important contribution to research evidence and to UK educational policy.
ISRCTN registry ISRCTN11339306 . Registered on 12 March 2020 (retrospectively registered).
该试验将研究全学校特殊教育需求审查对接受英语主流教育的中学生的影响,以了解该干预措施对学业成绩、幸福感和出勤率的影响。该审查旨在通过为学校特殊教育需求协调员和领导团队提供强化、持续的全纳教育支持与培训,促进全校变革。该试验将特别关注被认定有特殊教育需求或残疾的学生。
我们招募了160所英国中学(两个队列中约有58000名学生)参与一项双臂实用平行整群随机对照试验,在学校层面进行分配。随机分组将按学校所在地区分层。主要结局指标是被认定有特殊教育需求的学生(约4000名)的英语成绩(使用16岁时的标准化全国考试成绩)。将对有和没有特殊教育需求认定的学生测量次要结局指标,包括学生幸福感(使用优势与困难问卷进行测量)、缺勤和被开除情况,以及16岁时的数学和英语成绩。干预措施将于2021年7月实施,对(9年级队列的)结局指标的分析将于2023年9月进行,如果评估显示已实现可接受的实施保真度,则将于2024年9月对(8年级队列)进行进一步分析。
有特殊教育需求的学生是中学生群体中的一个重要且往往较为脆弱的部分,他们被学校开除、符合免费学校膳食资格或得到儿童社会护理支持的可能性过高。尽管存在这些多个重要的需求领域,但学校领导报告称,为这一群体提供额外支持面临重大挑战。先前的研究强调了发展全纳学校文化(而不是主要侧重于有针对性的个性化方法)的重要性。该试验将调查一项旨在推动全校变革的干预措施如何可能对有和没有特殊教育需求认定的学生产生影响。因此,预计该试验将对研究证据和英国教育政策做出重要贡献。
国际标准随机对照试验编号ISRCTN11339306。于2020年3月12日注册(追溯注册)。