School of Earth System Science, Institute of Surface-Earth System Science, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, China; Tianjin Hydraulic Science Research Institute, Tianjin 300061, China.
Tianjin Hydraulic Science Research Institute, Tianjin 300061, China.
J Environ Sci (China). 2021 Jun;104:40-52. doi: 10.1016/j.jes.2020.10.021. Epub 2020 Dec 10.
The Yongding New River is essential for the water supplies of Tianjin. To date, there is no comprehensive report that assesses the year-round water quality of the Yongding New River Main stream. Moreover, little attention has been given to determining a combined weight for improving the traditional comprehensive water quality identification index (ICWQII) by the game theory. Seven water quality parameters were investigated monthly along the main stream of the Yongding New River from May 2018 to April 2019. Organic contaminants and nitrogen pollution were mainly caused by point sources pollution, and the total phosphorus mainly by non-point source pollution. Dramatic spatio-temporal variations of water quality parameters were jointly caused by different pollutant sources and hydrometeorological factors. In terms of this study, an improved comprehensive water quality identification index (ICWQII) based on entropy weight or variation coefficient and traditional CWQII underestimated the water qualities, and an ICWQII based on the superstandard multiple method overvalued the assessments. By contrast, water qualities assessments done with an ICWQII based on the game theory matched perfectly with the practical situation. The ICWQII based on game theory proposed in this study takes into account not only the degree of disorder and variation of water quality data, but also the influence of standard-exceeded pollution indicators, whose results are relatively reasonable. All findings and the ICWQII based on game theory can provide scientific support for decisions related to the water environment management of the Yongding New River and other waters.
永定新河是天津的重要供水水源。迄今为止,尚无全面评估永定新河干流全年水质的报告。此外,很少有人关注通过博弈论来确定综合权重以改进传统综合水质识别指数 (ICWQII)。2018 年 5 月至 2019 年 4 月,每月沿永定新河干流调查了 7 个水质参数。有机污染物和氮污染主要由点源污染引起,总磷主要由非点源污染引起。水质参数的时空变化很大,这是由不同的污染源和水文气象因素共同造成的。就本研究而言,基于熵权或变异系数和传统 CWQII 的改进综合水质识别指数 (ICWQII) 低估了水质,而基于超标倍数法的 ICWQII 高估了评估结果。相比之下,基于博弈论的 ICWQII 评估与实际情况非常吻合。本研究提出的基于博弈论的 ICWQII 不仅考虑了水质数据的无序和变化程度,还考虑了超标污染指标的影响,其结果较为合理。所有发现和基于博弈论的 ICWQII 可为永定新河及其他水域的水环境管理决策提供科学依据。