Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2021 Jun 1;53(6):1270-1275. doi: 10.1249/MSS.0000000000002568.
The accurate quantification of the proportion of fat in human muscles could help monitor disease status and test effectiveness of interventions in people with neurological conditions whose skeletal muscles are frequently infiltrated with fat.
We compared two commonly used magnetic resonance imaging methods to quantify fat in muscles. Measurements were obtained before and after 6 or 8 wk of strength training in a total of 116 muscles spanning the range of intramuscular fat proportions observed in able-bodied young adults and people with spinal cord injury.
We successfully measured fat proportions in all muscles using the mDixon method but were unable to obtain plausible measurements with the T1-weighted method from muscles of able-bodied individuals or from the leaner 23% of muscles of people with spinal cord injury (muscles with less than approximately 8% fat). In muscles with more fat, measurements obtained with the two methods agreed well (intraclass correlation coefficient, 0.88; mean absolute difference, 5%). We also found that, compared with the T1-weighted method, the mDixon method provides a more detailed characterization of fat infiltration in muscle and a less variable measurement of the effect of training on the proportion of fat. The mDixon method showed that 6 or 8 wk of strength training did not appreciably change the proportion of intramuscular fat in either people with spinal cord injury or able-bodied people.
On the basis of these findings, we recommend the use of mDixon methods in preference to T1-weighted methods to determine the effectiveness of interventions aimed at reducing intramuscular fat.
准确量化人体肌肉中的脂肪比例有助于监测疾病状态,并测试神经疾病患者干预措施的有效性,这些患者的骨骼肌经常被脂肪浸润。
我们比较了两种常用于磁共振成像的方法来定量肌肉中的脂肪。在总共 116 块肌肉中,我们在力量训练前和 6 或 8 周后进行了测量,这些肌肉的范围涵盖了健康年轻人和脊髓损伤患者肌肉中观察到的脂肪比例。
我们成功地使用 mDixon 方法测量了所有肌肉的脂肪比例,但无法从健康个体的肌肉或脊髓损伤患者(脂肪比例低于约 8%的较瘦的 23%肌肉)中获得可靠的 T1 加权方法测量结果。在脂肪较多的肌肉中,两种方法的测量结果非常吻合(组内相关系数为 0.88;平均绝对差异为 5%)。我们还发现,与 T1 加权方法相比,mDixon 方法可以更详细地描述肌肉中的脂肪浸润,并更准确地测量训练对脂肪比例的影响。mDixon 方法表明,6 或 8 周的力量训练不会明显改变脊髓损伤患者或健康个体的肌肉内脂肪比例。
基于这些发现,我们建议使用 mDixon 方法代替 T1 加权方法来确定旨在减少肌肉内脂肪的干预措施的有效性。