Zhai Jinfang, Han Songyan, Guo Qinxiang, Shan Binbin, Wang Jing, Guo Yanrong, Tong Guoping, Zhao Chang, Li Yuan, Han Qiao, An Xiaoqin, Yue Ruiqing, Wang Li, Guo Tingting, Liu Zhentian, Xu Yaping, Li Jianqiang, Yang Weihua
Department of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, The Second Hospital of Shanxi Medical University, Taiyuan, China.
Department of Respiratory Ward One, Shanxi Provincial Cancer Hospital, Taiyuan, China.
Front Oncol. 2021 Apr 26;11:647216. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2021.647216. eCollection 2021.
With the rapid development of cancer genomics and immunomics, some new treatments of small cell lung cancer (SCLC) are emerging. However, there are limitations to the clinical use of tumor tissue. Our study aimed to evaluate the potential use of bronchial washing fluid (BWF) in the liquid biopsy of SCLC. Twenty-one extensive SCLC (ES-SCLC) patients were enrolled in this study. For all patients, four sample types, BWF supernatant (BWFs), BWF precipitate (BWFp), plasma and tumor tissue, were collected before receiving chemotherapy, and one type, plasma, was collected after chemotherapy. All samples were conducted to NGS using the 1021-gene panel. The concordance rates of genomic profiling using NGS in the four types of samples were evaluated. Multiple clinical information was analyzed for correlation. We successfully tested 20 BWFs samples, 21 BWFp samples, 21 tumor tissue samples, 20 pre-treatment plasma, and 13 post-treatment plasma of these 21 patients. The detectability of somatic mutations was 100% for BWFs, BWFp, tumor tissues, and post-treatment plasma, and only one pre-treatment plasma was absent with any mutation. Matched tumor tissue, BWFs, BWFp, and pre-treatment plasma samples were subsistent for 19 patients. For these patients, 204 genomic alterations were identified in tissue samples, while 189 (92.6%), 175 (85.5%), and 163 (79.9%) alterations were detected in the matched BWFs, BWFp, and pre-treatment plasma, respectively. Moreover, we found that the three tumor markers associated with SCLC have a lower sensitivity than genomic alterations. The endocrine resistance pathway was found enriched in hyponatremia patients which may be related to the hyponatremia. The TMBs of BWF, BWFp, and pre-treatment plasma samples all had a strong correlation with that of tissue samples. Both the VAF and the MVAF of mutations in post-treatment plasma were less than those in pre-treatment plasma, which was in accordance with the evaluation of curative effect. For ES-SCLC patients, the liquid biopsy of BWF showed a highly potential advantage to identify DNA alterations, which suggested that genomic analysis of BWF liquid biopsy may have clinical value as a supplement for tissue and blood detection. Through the restricted validation, it can be widely used in routine clinical practice.
随着癌症基因组学和免疫组学的快速发展,小细胞肺癌(SCLC)的一些新疗法正在涌现。然而,肿瘤组织的临床应用存在局限性。我们的研究旨在评估支气管冲洗液(BWF)在SCLC液体活检中的潜在用途。本研究纳入了21例广泛期小细胞肺癌(ES-SCLC)患者。对于所有患者,在接受化疗前收集四种样本类型,即BWF上清液(BWFs)、BWF沉淀物(BWFp)、血浆和肿瘤组织,化疗后收集一种样本类型,即血浆。所有样本使用1021基因panel进行二代测序(NGS)。评估了四种样本类型中使用NGS进行基因组分析的一致性率。分析了多种临床信息的相关性。我们成功检测了这21例患者的20份BWFs样本、21份BWFp样本、21份肿瘤组织样本、20份治疗前血浆和13份治疗后血浆。BWFs、BWFp、肿瘤组织和治疗后血浆中体细胞突变的可检测率为100%,只有一份治疗前血浆未检测到任何突变。19例患者有匹配的肿瘤组织、BWFs、BWFp和治疗前血浆样本。对于这些患者,在组织样本中鉴定出204种基因组改变,而在匹配的BWFs、BWFp和治疗前血浆中分别检测到189种(92.6%)、175种(85.5%)和163种(79.9%)改变。此外,我们发现与SCLC相关的三种肿瘤标志物的敏感性低于基因组改变。发现低钠血症患者的内分泌抵抗途径富集,这可能与低钠血症有关。BWF、BWFp和治疗前血浆样本的肿瘤突变负荷(TMB)均与组织样本的TMB有很强的相关性。治疗后血浆中突变的变异等位基因频率(VAF)和平均VAF均低于治疗前血浆,这与疗效评估一致。对于ES-SCLC患者,BWF液体活检在识别DNA改变方面显示出高度潜在优势,这表明BWF液体活检的基因组分析作为组织和血液检测的补充可能具有临床价值。通过有限验证,其可广泛应用于常规临床实践。