Fatih Mona, Barnett Matthew P G, Gillies Nicola A, Milan Amber M
Polytech School of Engineering, University of Angers, Angers, France.
AgResearch Ltd., Grasslands Research Centre, Palmerston North, New Zealand.
Front Nutr. 2021 Apr 30;8:643350. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2021.643350. eCollection 2021.
Most milk consumed by humans undergoes heat treatment to ensure microbiological safety and extend shelf life. Although heat treatment impacts the structure and physiochemical properties of milk, effects on nutrient absorption in humans are unclear. Therefore, a rapid review was performed to identify studies conducted on healthy human adult subjects that have assessed the impacts of heat treatment of milk on protein and fat digestion and metabolism in the postprandial period (up to 24 h). Relevant databases (Medline, EMBASE, Cochrane, Scopus) were systematically screened for intervention studies on healthy adult men and women that assessed the impact of consuming heat-treated milk on the postprandial kinetics or appearance in peripheral circulation or urine of ingested proteins and/or lipids. The risk-of-bias assessment tool 2 was used for quality assessment. Of 511 unique database records, 4 studies were included encompassing 6 study treatments ( = 57 participants, 20-68 years). Three studies evaluated pasteurization, two evaluated ultra-high temperature (UHT) treatment, and one evaluated oven-heated milk. Protein and lipid appearances in peripheral blood were reported in two sets of two studies. None of the studies used the same heat treatments and outcome measures, limiting generalization of effects. Protein appearance (ng/mL or area under the curve) (as plasma amino acids - lysine) was reduced when milk was oven-heated for 5 h in one study ( = 7 participants), while the other study reported a reduced retention of dietary N with UHT milk ( = 25 participants). Overall plasma triacylglycerol responses were unaffected by milk heat treatments reported, but plasma fatty acid composition differed. The studies observed higher plasma myristic and palmitic acid abundance with successive heat treatment at 2 h ( = 11 participants; pasteurized) and 4 h ( = 14 participants; UHT) after ingestion; other differences were inconsistent. All studies had moderate-high risk of bias, which should be taken into consideration when interpreting findings. This review identified few studies reporting the effects of milk heat treatment on postprandial nutrient responses in adults. Although the findings suggest that milk heat treatment likely affects postprandial protein and lipid dynamics, generalization of the findings is limited as treatments, outcomes, and methods differed across studies. Because of the study variability, and the acute post-prandial nature of the studies, it is also difficult to draw conclusions regarding potential long-term health outcomes. However, the possibility that altered digestive kinetics may influence postprandial protein retention and anabolic use of dietary N suggests heat treatment of milk may impact outcomes such as long-term maintenance of muscle mass.
人类消费的大多数牛奶都经过热处理,以确保微生物安全并延长保质期。尽管热处理会影响牛奶的结构和理化性质,但对人体营养吸收的影响尚不清楚。因此,进行了一项快速综述,以确定对健康成年受试者进行的研究,这些研究评估了牛奶热处理对餐后阶段(长达24小时)蛋白质和脂肪消化及代谢的影响。对相关数据库(Medline、EMBASE、Cochrane、Scopus)进行系统筛选,以查找关于健康成年男性和女性的干预研究,这些研究评估了饮用热处理牛奶对摄入蛋白质和/或脂质的餐后动力学、外周循环或尿液中出现情况的影响。使用偏倚风险评估工具2进行质量评估。在511条独特的数据库记录中,纳入了4项研究,涵盖6种研究处理(n = 57名参与者,20 - 68岁)。三项研究评估了巴氏杀菌,两项评估了超高温(UHT)处理,一项评估了烤箱加热牛奶。两组两项研究报告了外周血中蛋白质和脂质的出现情况。没有一项研究使用相同的热处理和结果测量方法,限制了结果的普遍性。在一项研究(n = 7名参与者)中,牛奶在烤箱中加热5小时后,蛋白质出现量(ng/mL或曲线下面积)(以血浆氨基酸 - 赖氨酸计)降低,而另一项研究报告超高温处理牛奶的膳食氮保留量降低(n = 25名参与者)。所报告的牛奶热处理对总体血浆三酰甘油反应没有影响,但血浆脂肪酸组成有所不同。研究观察到,摄入后在2小时(n = 11名参与者;巴氏杀菌)和4小时(n = 14名参与者;超高温处理)连续热处理后,血浆肉豆蔻酸和棕榈酸丰度较高;其他差异不一致。所有研究都有中度至高度的偏倚风险,在解释结果时应予以考虑。本综述发现很少有研究报告牛奶热处理对成年人餐后营养反应的影响。尽管研究结果表明牛奶热处理可能会影响餐后蛋白质和脂质动态,但由于各研究的处理、结果和方法不同,结果的普遍性有限。由于研究的变异性以及研究的急性餐后性质,也难以就潜在的长期健康结果得出结论。然而,消化动力学改变可能影响餐后蛋白质保留和膳食氮的合成代谢利用,这表明牛奶热处理可能会影响诸如肌肉质量长期维持等结果。