Chun Chun Ki, Wong Frances Ky, Wang Shao Ling, Chen Weiju
Adult Intensive Care Unit, Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China.
School of Nursing, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China.
Int J Nurs Sci. 2021 Mar 5;8(2):190-198. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnss.2021.03.001. eCollection 2021 Apr 10.
There were studies evaluating advanced nursing practice independently in the mainland and Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of China, but there was no attempt to make a comparison of practice between them. This study employed a case study method to examine and compare advanced nursing practice in Hong Kong and Guangzhou.
Purposive sampling method was used to recruit 24 advanced practice nurses (APN) who came from the specialty of medical, surgical and pediatric in Hong Kong and Guangzhou. A questionnaire survey and semi-structured interview were conducted to solicit quantitative and qualitative data for exploring the structure-process-outcome of advanced nursing practice. The structure component explored the factors influencing advanced nursing practice. The process part examined APN role components and illustrations of exemplary advanced nursing practice. The outcomes described outcome indicators that best reflected advanced nursing practice.
Findings revealed that in the structure domain, APN education and career development, team approach in healthcare, and support from management, physicians and professional associations were important contextual factors for APN development in both cities. For the process domain, participants had at least 80% of their time practicing independently/interdependently and were engaged in APN activities including direct/indirect patient care, research/project work, initiation of staff and patient protocols. All participants demonstrated competencies with impacts on patient, service and profession in their description of exemplary practice. Participants from both cities ranked patient-related outcomes as top indicators for their advanced nursing practice.
This study has revealed that APNs in Guangzhou and Hong Kong shared similar work involvement and impacts and their demonstrated competencies were on par with international counterparts. Continued efforts need to be put in establishing formal APN education, clear clinical career pathway and title protection to empower nurses to provide optimal care to the fullest extent that they are prepared for.
在中国内地和香港特别行政区有对高级护理实践进行独立评估的研究,但尚未尝试对两地的实践进行比较。本研究采用案例研究方法来考察和比较香港和广州的高级护理实践。
采用目的抽样法招募了24名来自香港和广州的医疗、外科和儿科专业的高级实践护士(APN)。进行了问卷调查和半结构化访谈,以获取定量和定性数据,用于探索高级护理实践的结构-过程-结果。结构部分探讨了影响高级护理实践的因素。过程部分考察了APN的角色组成部分以及典型高级护理实践的实例。结果部分描述了最能反映高级护理实践的结果指标。
研究结果显示,在结构领域,APN的教育和职业发展、医疗保健中的团队方法以及来自管理层、医生和专业协会的支持是两个城市APN发展的重要背景因素。在过程领域,参与者至少80%的时间独立/相互依赖地开展实践,并参与包括直接/间接患者护理、研究/项目工作、制定员工和患者方案在内的APN活动。所有参与者在描述典型实践时都展示了对患者、服务和专业有影响的能力。两个城市的参与者都将与患者相关的结果列为高级护理实践的首要指标。
本研究表明,广州和香港的APN在工作参与度和影响方面相似,他们所展示的能力与国际同行相当。需要继续努力建立正规的APN教育、明确的临床职业路径和头衔保护,以使护士能够在其准备充分的最大程度上提供最佳护理。