Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Seoul National University, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Department of Transportation Engineering, College of Engineering, Keimyung University, Daegu, Republic of Korea.
PLoS One. 2021 May 18;16(5):e0251866. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0251866. eCollection 2021.
Detecting high-collision-concentration locations based solely on collision frequency may produce different results compared to those considering the severities of the collisions. In particular, it can lead government agencies focusing sites with a high collision frequency while neglecting those with a lower collision frequency but a higher percentage of injury and fatal collisions. This study developed systematic ways of detecting reproducible fatal collision locations (R) using the naïve Bayes approach and a continuous risk profile (CRP) that estimates the true collision risk by filtering out random noise in the data. The posterior probability of fatal collisions being reproducible at a location is estimated by the relationship between the spatial distribution of fatal-collision locations (i.e., likelihood) and the CRP (i.e., prior probability). The proposed method can be used to detect sites with the highest proxy measure of the posterior probability (PMP) of observing R. An empirical evaluation using 5-year traffic collision data from six routes in California shows that detecting R based on the PMP outperform those based on the SPF-based approaches or random selection, regardless of various conditions and parameters of the proposed method. This method only requires traffic collision and annual traffic volume data to estimate PMP that prioritize sites being R and the PMPs can be compared across multiple routes. Therefore, it helps government agencies prioritizing sites of multiple routes where the number of fatal collisions can be reduced, thus help them to save lives with limited resources of data collection.
仅基于碰撞频率检测高碰撞集中地点的结果可能与同时考虑碰撞严重程度的结果不同。特别是,这可能导致政府机构关注碰撞频率高的地点,而忽略碰撞频率较低但受伤和致命碰撞比例较高的地点。本研究使用朴素贝叶斯方法和连续风险剖面 (CRP) 开发了可重复致命碰撞地点 (R) 的系统检测方法,该方法通过过滤数据中的随机噪声来估计真实碰撞风险。通过致命碰撞地点的空间分布(即似然)和 CRP(即先验概率)之间的关系来估计地点上致命碰撞重现的后验概率。所提出的方法可用于检测具有最高观察到 R 的后验概率(PMP)的代理测量值的地点。使用加利福尼亚州六条路线的五年交通碰撞数据进行的实证评估表明,无论所提出方法的各种条件和参数如何,基于 PMP 检测 R 比基于 SPF 方法或随机选择的方法效果更好。该方法仅需要交通碰撞和年交通量数据来估计 PMP,以优先考虑 R 的地点,并且可以在多个路线之间比较 PMP。因此,它可以帮助政府机构对致命碰撞数量可减少的多个路线的地点进行优先排序,从而帮助他们在数据收集资源有限的情况下挽救生命。