de Andrade Dominique, Coomber Kerri, Ferris Jason, PuljeviĆ Cheneal, Burn Michele, Vakidis Thea, Taylor Nicholas, Mayshak Richelle, Grant Kristy, Patafio Brittany, Miller Peter G
School of Psychology, Deakin University, Geelong, Australia.
School of Psychology, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia.
Drug Alcohol Rev. 2021 Jul;40(5):728-737. doi: 10.1111/dar.13299. Epub 2021 May 20.
On 1 July 2016, stage 1 of the Tackling Alcohol-Fuelled Violence (TAFV) policy was introduced in Queensland, Australia and included restricted alcohol service to 03:00 in dedicated entertainment precincts (safe night precincts or SNPs). During stage 2 (from 1 February 2017), the number of extended trading permits (i.e. trading until 05:00) per venue were reduced; and during stage 3 (from 1 July 2017), networked identification scanners were mandated for late-night venues. We aim to examine whether patron drinking behaviours in two key SNPs changed significantly following stages 2 and 3.
The study design was repeated cross-sectional, with three data collection (policy) stages. Patrons street surveys were conducted in Fortitude Valley (n = 2066) and Cairns (n = 1021) SNPs between July 2016 and November 2018. Linear or negative binomial regressions were conducted to examine changes in three key outcomes: blood alcohol concentration (BAC) reading, proportion of pre-drinkers and number of pre-drinks.
We found no significant difference in BAC reading, proportion of pre-drinkers or number of pre-drinks at stages 2 and 3 of the policy compared to baseline in Fortitude Valley. In Cairns, we found significant reductions in patron BAC at stage 3 of the policy, and female BAC at stages 2 and 3 compared to baseline; while the proportion of females pre-drinking significantly reduced by half in stage 2.
Despite evidence of some reductions in alcohol consumption, high levels of intoxication remain, suggesting harm reduction may be more difficult to achieve in these drinkers.
2016年7月1日,澳大利亚昆士兰州推出了应对酒精引发暴力行为(TAFV)政策的第一阶段,其中包括在专门的娱乐区(安全夜间区或SNP)将酒精销售限制至凌晨3点。在第二阶段(从2017年2月1日起),每个场所的延长营业时间许可证数量(即营业至凌晨5点)有所减少;在第三阶段(从2017年7月1日起),要求深夜营业场所配备联网身份识别扫描仪。我们旨在研究在该政策的第二和第三阶段之后,两个主要SNP地区的顾客饮酒行为是否发生了显著变化。
本研究设计为重复横断面研究,包括三个数据收集(政策)阶段。2016年7月至2018年11月期间,在毅力谷(n = 2066)和凯恩斯(n = 1021)的SNP地区对顾客进行了街头调查。进行线性或负二项式回归以研究三个关键结果的变化:血液酒精浓度(BAC)读数、饮酒前人群比例和饮酒前次数。
我们发现,与毅力谷的基线相比,该政策第二和第三阶段的BAC读数、饮酒前人群比例或饮酒前次数没有显著差异。在凯恩斯,我们发现该政策第三阶段顾客的BAC显著降低,第二和第三阶段女性的BAC与基线相比显著降低;而在第二阶段,女性饮酒前的比例显著降低了一半。
尽管有证据表明酒精消费有所减少,但仍有大量醉酒现象,这表明在这些饮酒者中更难实现减少伤害的目标。