Programa de Pós-graduação em Fonoaudiologia, Departamento de Fonoaudiologia, Faculdade de Filosofia e Ciências - UNESP - Marília (SP), Brasil.
Codas. 2021 May 21;33(3):e20200009. doi: 10.1590/2317-1782/20202020009. eCollection 2021.
To analyze the immediate effect of laryngeal surface hydration associated with the performance of Tongue Trills (TT) on singers.
Thirty singers without vocal complaints or laryngeal alterations divided into control (CG) and experimental (EG) groups. The CG performed the TT for five minutes. The EG was submitted a nebulization with 3 ml of saline solution followed by TT for five minutes. Voice self-assessment, acoustic analysis and perceptual assessment were performed at Pre (Pre TT) and post (PTT) moments in CG and pre (Pre TT), post hydration (PH) and post hydration + TT (PHTT) in GE. In the self-assessment were evaluated quality, stability, vocal intensity and hoarseness. There were extract the values of the Fundamental frequency; Jitter%; Shimmer%, Noise-to-harmonic Ratio e Cepstral Peak Prominence-Smoothed (CPPs) in the acoustic analyze. The perceptual evaluation was performed by an experienced speech therapist.
Comparing the results of self-assessment between groups showed improvement in the perception of stability and vocal intensity in the PTT (CG) in relation to PH (EG). Comparison between the EG moments showed a statistical difference in the vocal intensity perception, indicating a better results for PHTT. There was no statistical difference between the groups investigated in the perceptual assessments and acoustic analysis.
Surface laryngeal hydration does not potentiate the effect of TT on naturally hydrated singers with 3ml nebulization. For voice professionals with high vocal demand, surface hydration can be introduced during voice use to maintain vocal quality.
分析与颤音(TT)表现相关的喉表面水合作用对歌手的即时影响。
30 名无嗓音抱怨或喉改变的歌手分为对照组(CG)和实验组(EG)。CG 进行了五分钟的 TT。EG 接受了 3 毫升生理盐水的雾化处理,随后进行了五分钟的 TT。在 CG 的预 TT(Pre TT)和后 TT(PTT)时刻以及 EG 的预 TT(Pre TT)、水合后(PH)和水合后+TT(PHTT)时刻进行了嗓音自我评估、声学分析和感知评估。在自我评估中,评估了质量、稳定性、发声强度和嘶哑度。在声学分析中提取了基频值、抖动%、颤抖%、噪声与谐波比和倒频谱峰突出度-平滑(CPPs)。感知评估由一位经验丰富的语音治疗师进行。
在组间比较中,与 PH(EG)相比,CG 的 PTT 时自我评估中的稳定性和发声强度感知有所改善。EG 各时刻之间的比较显示,发声强度感知存在统计学差异,表明 PHTT 效果更好。在感知评估和声学分析方面,两组之间均无统计学差异。
对于接受 3ml 雾化处理的自然水合歌手,喉表面水合作用不会增强 TT 的效果。对于高嗓音需求的专业嗓音人士,可以在使用嗓音时引入表面水合作用来维持嗓音质量。