White A J, Barraclough B
University Department of Psychiatry, Royal South Hants Hospital, Southampton, U.K.
J Psychosom Res. 1988;32(1):99-106. doi: 10.1016/0022-3999(88)90093-1.
The notes of 1007 consecutive admissions to a District General Hospital adult psychiatry unit were examined retrospectively to establish the role of the thyroid disease detected in routine management. Thyroid function tests were performed on 300 admissions, leaving 707 untested. Ten had abnormal results (3.3% of admissions tested), accounted for by nine patients with affective disorder. Two of the nine settled spontaneously, but seven cases (2.3%) had sustained abnormality. Five of the seven had a known history of thyroid disease, leaving two new findings of hypothyroidism who presented with no clinical signs other than their mental illness (0.7% of admissions tested). In five cases, which included the two new findings, the thyroid disease had been judged to precipitate the mental illness. All cases except one transitory abnormality occurred in females. When the results of this and other surveys are compared with the figures for thyroid disease in the general population, the value of screening psychiatric patients seems questionable. However, diagnosis is important in a few cases where thyroid disease apparently contributes to the mental illness. For psychiatric patients aged up to 65, elimination of unnecessary thyroid function tests without sacrificing detection may be possible by restricting use to female patients with affective disorder, patients with a past or family history of thyroid disease or with presenile dementia. Abnormal results obtained during the acute phase of the illness may be transitory and require confirmation.
对一家地区综合医院成人精神科连续收治的1007例患者的病历进行回顾性研究,以确定在常规管理中检测到的甲状腺疾病的作用。对300例患者进行了甲状腺功能测试,其余707例未进行测试。10例结果异常(占测试患者的3.3%),均为情感障碍患者。9例中有2例自行缓解,但7例(2.3%)持续异常。7例中有5例有甲状腺疾病史,另外2例为新发甲状腺功能减退,除精神疾病外无其他临床症状(占测试患者的0.7%)。在包括这2例新发病例在内的5例中,甲状腺疾病被判定为诱发精神疾病。除1例短暂异常外,所有病例均发生在女性。将本研究及其他调查结果与普通人群中的甲状腺疾病数据进行比较时,筛查精神科患者的价值似乎值得怀疑。然而,在少数甲状腺疾病明显导致精神疾病的病例中,诊断很重要。对于65岁以下的精神科患者,通过将检测限制在患有情感障碍的女性患者、有甲状腺疾病既往史或家族史的患者或患有早老性痴呆的患者身上,在不影响检测的情况下消除不必要的甲状腺功能测试可能是可行的。疾病急性期获得的异常结果可能是短暂的,需要进行确认。