Faculty of Psychology and Education Sciences, University of Porto, Portugal.
School of Health, Polytechnic of Porto, Portugal.
Br J Educ Psychol. 2021 Dec;91(4):1456-1480. doi: 10.1111/bjep.12430. Epub 2021 Jun 7.
Writing is a particularly demanding activity, which poses unique motivational challenges for students. Despite the wealth of research on the relation between writing motivation and writing performance, little is known about the role of students' writing frequency in writing motivation and writing performance.
We aimed to: (1) examine structural relations among two motivational variables (i.e., self-efficacy and attitudes), a behavioural variable (i.e., writing frequency), and writing performance; and (2) inspect whether these relations varied across two text genres (i.e., narrative and opinion texts) and across two educational levels (i.e., students in grades 5-6 and grades 7-8).
Six hundred and five students from grades 5-8 participated in this study.
Students completed self-report scales and wrote narrative and opinion texts. We conducted multiple-group structural equation modeling to analyse the data.
Regarding narrative texts, digital writing frequency was significantly associated with text quality for students in grades 7-8, but this relation was not significant in students from grades 5-6. Both attitudes and self-efficacy for self-regulation made a direct contribution to narrative text quality across educational levels. In addition, attitudes were associated with both literary and digital writing frequency across educational levels. Concerning opinion texts, no significant differences emerged in terms of educational level. Attitudes contributed to both literary and digital writing frequency as well as to opinion text quality across educational levels.
This study underlines the fundamental contribution of motivational variables to students' writing performance. Accordingly, teachers need to adopt motivation-enhancing practices in writing instruction across grade levels.
写作是一项特别要求高的活动,这给学生带来了独特的动机挑战。尽管有大量关于写作动机与写作表现之间关系的研究,但对于学生写作频率在写作动机和写作表现中的作用知之甚少。
我们旨在:(1) 考察两个动机变量(自我效能感和态度)、一个行为变量(写作频率)与写作表现之间的结构关系;(2) 检验这些关系在两种文本类型(叙事和观点文本)和两个教育水平(5-6 年级和 7-8 年级学生)之间是否存在差异。
605 名 5-8 年级学生参加了这项研究。
学生完成了自我报告量表,并撰写了叙事和观点文本。我们进行了多组结构方程模型分析来处理数据。
关于叙事文本,对于 7-8 年级的学生来说,数字写作频率与文本质量显著相关,但对于 5-6 年级的学生来说,这种关系并不显著。自我调节的态度和自我效能感都直接有助于不同教育水平的叙事文本质量。此外,态度与不同教育水平的文学和数字写作频率都相关。关于观点文本,在教育水平方面没有出现显著差异。态度对文学和数字写作频率以及观点文本质量都有贡献,跨越了教育水平。
本研究强调了动机变量对学生写作表现的基本贡献。因此,教师需要在跨年级的写作教学中采取增强动机的实践。