Yang Q D, Chen W, Mu M D, Zhang C K, Yang A N, Tao X, Xie M M, Tang K L
Orthopaedic Sports Medicine Center, the First Affiliated Hospital to Army Medical University, Chongqing 400038, China.
Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2021 Jun 1;59(6):470-476. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn112139-20201021-00762.
To examine the preliminary clinical efficacy of custom-made three-dimensional(3D) printed talus prosthesis in the treatment of collapse talus necrosis. The clinical data of 8 patients who received 3D printed custom-made talus prostheses replacement for severe collapsed necrosis of the talus at the Orthopaedic Sports Medical Center, the First Affiliated Hospital to Army Medical University were analyzed retrospectively.All patients were male,with an average age of 38.0 years (range:22 to 65 years).There were 5 cases of left talus collapse and 3 cases of right talus collapse,with the course of disease of 29.7 weeks (range:6 to 96 weeks).The CT data of contralateral healthy talus were used for mirror image design references for the prosthesis,and the electron-beam 3D printing technology was used to prepare the prosthesis.Titanium alloy (Ti6Al4V) was taken as the material for the preparation of the talus body prosthesis,and Co-Cr-Mo material was used as the material for the preparation of the tibialis talus lateral joint surface prosthesis,and the subtalar joint surface of the prosthesis was made from a microporous casting technique.The prosthesis was analyzed preoperatively by digital three-dimensional finite element analysis and solid comparison techniques to measure anatomic match of the prosthesis.A longitudinal incision on medial ankle was made.The necrotic talus was completely removed and the prosthesis was then implanted.The patient was reexamined in the outpatient department 3, 6, and 12 months after surgery.Primary outcome measures were the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society(AOFAS) ankle-hind foot score,visual analogue scale(VAS) and ankle range of motion.Changes in imaging data and plantar pressure were also assessed.Repeated measures analysis of variance and paired- test were used to compare the data. The talus prosthesis measure preoperatively was completely consistent with that contralateral healthy talus and there was no operation-related complication. All the wounds healed primarily. The patients were followed up effectively for 23.17 months (range:12 to 48 months).The preoperative dorsiflexion of patients was (7.6±5.7)°,it increased to(14.2±6.6)° at 12 month after surgery (=-2.67,=0.03).The plantar flexion increased from (22.0±9.9)°preoperatively to (29.2±8.7)° at 12 month after surgery (=-8.95,<0.01).Preoperative AOFAS ankle-hind foot score was 26.3±6.6,and it increased to 70.1±2.2,76.0±3.4 and 79.3±4.2 at 3 month,6 month and 12 month after surgery(=56.81,<0.01);Pre-operative VAS was[()]3.0(0.8),and it increased to 2.5(1.0),1.5(1.0),1.0(1.0)at 3 month,6 month and 12 month after surgery(=20.00,<0.01).At the last follow-up,imaging reexamination showed that the prosthesis of all patients were in stable position with no sign of subsidence.No secondary ankle fusion or revision was required.The talus height increased from (27.6±6.0)mm preoperatively to (34.6±3.5)mm (=-2.94,<0.01).The plantar pressure showed that the maximum pressure on the healthy ankle was(629.9±26.1)N,and that on the affected side was(521.4±14.4)N.The pressure on the healthy ankle was(350.6±29.6)N,and that on the necrotic side was (212.3±9.7)N.The load on the contralateral forefoot was(38.1±2.8)% and that on the necrotic side was(11.5±2.0)%.The load on the contralateral hindfoot was (24.6±2.5)% and that on the necrotic side was (21.1±1.8)%. The custom-made 3D printed talus prosthesis could restore the talus anatomy,recover the ankle joint function,relieve the pain of patients and improve the life quality of patients.The effect on plantar pressure is mainly achieved by adjusting the center of gravity of plantar pressure backwards and the increase of weight bearing of the healthy foot.
探讨定制三维(3D)打印距骨假体治疗距骨塌陷坏死的初步临床疗效。回顾性分析陆军军医大学第一附属医院骨科运动医学中心8例接受3D打印定制距骨假体置换治疗重度距骨塌陷坏死患者的临床资料。所有患者均为男性,平均年龄38.0岁(范围:22至65岁)。左侧距骨塌陷5例,右侧距骨塌陷3例,病程29.7周(范围:6至96周)。以健侧距骨的CT数据为假体镜像设计参考,采用电子束3D打印技术制备假体。采用钛合金(Ti6Al4V)制备距骨体假体,采用钴铬钼材料制备胫距外侧关节面假体,假体的距下关节面采用微孔铸造技术制作。术前通过数字三维有限元分析和实体比对技术对假体进行分析,以测量假体的解剖匹配度。在内踝做纵行切口。彻底切除坏死距骨,然后植入假体。术后3、6和12个月在门诊对患者进行复查。主要观察指标为美国矫形足踝协会(AOFAS)踝后足评分、视觉模拟量表(VAS)和踝关节活动度。还评估了影像学数据和足底压力的变化。采用重复测量方差分析和配对检验比较数据。术前测量的距骨假体与健侧距骨完全一致,未发生与手术相关的并发症。所有伤口均一期愈合。对患者进行了有效随访23.17个月(范围:12至48个月)。患者术前背屈为(7.6±5.7)°,术后12个月增加至(14.2±6.6)°(t=-2.67,P=0.03)。跖屈从术前的(22.0±9.9)°增加至术后12个月的(29.2±8.7)°(t=-8.95,P<0.01)。术前AOFAS踝后足评分为26.3±6.6,术后3个月、6个月和12个月分别增至70.1±2.2、76.0±3.4和79.3±4.2(F=56.81,P<0.01);术前VAS为[()]3.0(0.8),术后3个月、6个月和12个月分别增至2.5(1.0)、1.5(1.0)、1.0(1.0)(F=20.00,P<0.01)。末次随访时,影像学复查显示所有患者的假体位置稳定,无下沉迹象。无需二次踝关节融合或翻修。距骨高度从术前的(27.6±6.0)mm增加至(34.6±3.5)mm(t=-2.94,P<0.01)。足底压力显示,健侧踝关节最大压力为(629.9±26.1)N,患侧为(521.4±14.4)N。健侧足底压力为(350.6±29.6)N,坏死侧为(212.3±9.7)N。对侧前足负荷为(38.1±2.8)%,坏死侧为(11.5±2.0)%。对侧后足负荷为(24.6±2.5)%,坏死侧为(21.1±1.8)%。定制的3D打印距骨假体可恢复距骨解剖结构,恢复踝关节功能,缓解患者疼痛,提高患者生活质量。对足底压力的影响主要通过将足底压力重心后移和健侧足部负重增加来实现。