General Internal Medicine, Department of Medicine, Geneva University Hospitals, Geneva, Switzerland.
Faculty of Medicine, Geneva University, Geneva, Switzerland.
Intern Emerg Med. 2022 Jan;17(1):113-122. doi: 10.1007/s11739-021-02781-1. Epub 2021 Jun 20.
Physical examination (PE) has always been a corner stone of medical practice. The recent advances in imaging and fading of doctors' ability in performing it, however, raised doubts on PE usefulness. Point-of-care ultrasonography (POCUS) is gaining ground in medicine with the detection of free fluids being one of its main applications. To estimate physicians' confidence and use of PE and POCUS for the detection of abdominal or pleural free fluid, we conducted a cross-sectional survey. In all, 246 internal and emergency medicine physicians answered to the survey (197 in-hospital physicians and 49 general practitioners; response rate 28.5%). Almost all declared to perform PE in case of suspected ascites or pleural effusion (88% and 90%, respectively). The highest rates of confidence were observed in conventional PE signs (91% for diminished breath sounds, 80% for dullness to thorax percussion, and 66% for abdominal flank dullness). For the remaining signs, rates of confidence were less than 53%. Physicians with > 15 years of experience and POCUS-naïve doctors reported higher confidence in PE. Most of emergency and almost half of internal medicine physicians (78% and 44%, respectively) attended a structured POCUS course. POCUS use was higher among trained physicians for both ascites (84% vs 50%, p < 0.001) and pleural effusion (80% vs 34%, p < 0.001). Similarly, higher POCUS use was observed in younger physicians. In conclusion, PE is frequently performed and rates of confidence are low for most PE signs, especially among young doctors and POCUS users. This detailed inventory suggests an ongoing shift towards POCUS integration in clinical practice.
体格检查(PE)一直是医学实践的基石。然而,影像学技术的进步以及医生进行体格检查能力的下降,使得人们对其是否有用产生了怀疑。即时床旁超声检查(POCUS)在医学领域的应用越来越广泛,检测游离液体是其主要应用之一。为了评估医生对 PE 和 POCUS 检测腹部或胸腔游离液体的信心和使用情况,我们进行了一项横断面调查。共有 246 名内科和急诊医生回答了这项调查(197 名住院医生和 49 名全科医生;应答率为 28.5%)。几乎所有医生都表示在怀疑腹水或胸腔积液时会进行 PE(分别为 88%和 90%)。在传统的 PE 体征中,医生的信心最高(91%的人认为呼吸音减弱,80%的人认为胸部叩诊浊音,66%的人认为腹部侧腹叩诊浊音)。对于其余的体征,信心程度低于 53%。经验超过 15 年的医生和 POCUS 新手医生报告对 PE 的信心更高。大多数急诊医生和近一半的内科医生(分别为 78%和 44%)参加了结构化的 POCUS 课程。接受过培训的医生在诊断腹水(84%比 50%,p<0.001)和胸腔积液(80%比 34%,p<0.001)时更倾向于使用 POCUS。同样,年轻医生更倾向于使用 POCUS。总之,PE 经常被使用,但大多数 PE 体征的信心程度较低,尤其是在年轻医生和 POCUS 用户中。这项详细的调查表明,POCUS 在临床实践中的整合正在进行。