Pollak R, Baker R J
Department of Surgery, University of Illinois College of Medicine, Chicago 60680.
Am Surg. 1988 Sep;54(9):531-4.
Conferences and seminars are mandated integral components of modern surgical residency programs. We studied the attendance records of house staff at these seminars, as well as an objective measure of cognitive performance (scores achieved in the ABSITE) to determine the role of the teaching seminar in the acquisition of factual knowledge by residents. Seventy five to 85 residents attended weekly scheduled seminars conducted by faculty on a wide range of surgical topics. Attendance records were kept for postgraduate years 1-5 (PGY1-PGY5) and the percentage of residents attending at all conference encounters was calculated. Individual resident ABSITE scores were pooled for each postgraduate year, and expressed as a mean (+/- standard deviation). PGY1 and PGY2 house staff attended conferences poorly (32% and 25% respectively). A marked increase to 56 per cent was noted for the PGY3 level (P less than 0.001), but failed to rise thereafter in the PGY4 and PGY5 years (56% and 52%). ABSITE scores rise with time and progressive seniority, although mean scores remain constant for given postgraduate years. Varying somewhat with the graduating class, PGY5 scores tend to be substantially better than in the PGY1 and PGY2 years. No correlation could be demonstrated between the patterns of conference attendance and the ABSITE scores for each graduating class (r = 0.761; P greater than 0.05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
会议和研讨会是现代外科住院医师培训项目必不可少的组成部分。我们研究了住院医师参加这些研讨会的出勤记录,以及认知表现的客观指标(美国外科学会外科知识考试[ABSITE]的成绩),以确定教学研讨会在住院医师获取事实性知识方面所起的作用。75至85名住院医师参加了由教员每周安排的关于广泛外科主题的研讨会。记录了研究生1至5年级(PGY1 - PGY5)的出勤情况,并计算了参加所有会议的住院医师百分比。汇总了每个研究生年级住院医师的个人ABSITE成绩,并表示为平均值(±标准差)。PGY1和PGY2的住院医师参加会议的情况较差(分别为32%和25%)。PGY3级别的参会率显著提高到56%(P小于0.001),但在PGY4和PGY5年级没有进一步上升(分别为56%和52%)。ABSITE成绩随时间和资历的增加而提高,尽管特定研究生年级的平均成绩保持不变。PGY5的成绩因毕业班级不同而略有差异,但往往比PGY1和PGY2年级要好得多。每个毕业班级的会议出勤模式与ABSITE成绩之间没有相关性(r = 0.761;P大于0.05)。(摘要截短为250字)