Department of Surgery, Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center, New Orleans, La.
Department of Surgery, Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center, New Orleans, La.
J Vasc Surg. 2021 Dec;74(6):2064-2071.e5. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2021.05.045. Epub 2021 Jun 25.
In the present study, we sought to understand the challenges, advantages, and applications of a vascular surgery virtual subinternship (VSI) curriculum.
Our institution hosted 25 students for two 4-week VSI rotations, one in July 2020 and one in August 2020. The students participated in a curriculum centered around the use of Zoom and telephone interactions with residents and faculty. The curriculum included selected readings, surgical videos, group didactics, and one-on-one mentorship. Anonymous pre- and postrotation self-assessments were used to ascertain the students' achievement of the learning objectives and the utility of the educational tools implemented during the rotation. The faculty and resident mentors were also surveyed to assess their experience.
With the exception of knot-tying techniques (P = .67), the students reported significant improvement in their understanding of vascular surgery concepts after the virtual elective (P < .05). The highest ranked components of the course were interpersonal, including interaction with faculty, mentorship, and learning the program culture. The lowest ranked components of the course were simulation training and research opportunities. The rating of the utility of aspects of the course were consistent with the ranking of the components, with faculty interaction receiving the highest average rating. The ideal amount of time for daily virtual interaction reported by the students ranged from 3 to 6 hours (median, 4 hours). Overall, most of the mentors were satisfied with the virtual course. However, they reported limited ability to assess the students' personality and fit for the program. The time spent per week by the mentors on the virtual vascular surgery rotation ranged from 2 to 7 hours (median, 4 hours). Of the 17 mentors completing the surveys, 14 reported that having a virtual student was a significant addition to their existing workload.
Overall, our student and mentor feedback was positive. Several challenges inherent to the virtual environment still require refinement. However, the goals of a VSI are distinct and should be explored by training programs. With changes to healthcare in the United States on the horizon and the constraints resulting from the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 pandemic, implementing a virtual away rotation could be an acceptable platform in our adaptations of our recruitment strategies.
本研究旨在了解血管外科学虚拟实习(VSI)课程的挑战、优势和应用。
我们机构在 2020 年 7 月和 2020 年 8 月期间接待了 25 名学生进行为期 4 周的 VSI 轮转,学生们参与了以使用 Zoom 和与住院医师和教师进行电话交流为中心的课程。该课程包括选择性阅读、手术视频、小组讲座和一对一指导。在轮转期间,通过匿名的轮转前后自我评估来确定学生是否达到学习目标以及教育工具的实用性。还对教师和住院医师导师进行了调查,以评估他们的经验。
除了打结技术(P=.67)之外,学生们报告说,在虚拟选修课程后,他们对血管外科学概念的理解有了显著提高(P<.05)。课程中排名最高的部分是人际交往,包括与教师的互动、指导和学习项目文化。课程中排名最低的部分是模拟培训和研究机会。课程各方面的实用性评分与课程各部分的评分一致,教师互动获得了最高的平均评分。学生们报告的每天虚拟互动的理想时间范围是 3 到 6 小时(中位数为 4 小时)。总的来说,大多数导师对虚拟课程感到满意。然而,他们报告说,评估学生的个性和适应项目的能力有限。导师每周在虚拟血管外科学轮转上花费的时间从 2 到 7 小时不等(中位数为 4 小时)。在完成调查的 17 位导师中,有 14 位表示,有一名虚拟学生是对他们现有工作量的重要补充。
总的来说,我们的学生和导师的反馈是积极的。虚拟环境固有的一些挑战仍需要改进。然而,VSI 的目标是明确的,应该由培训计划来探索。随着美国医疗保健的变化和严重急性呼吸系统综合征冠状病毒 2 大流行带来的限制,实施虚拟轮岗可能是我们调整招聘策略的一个可接受的平台。