Cha Elliot D K, Lynch Conor P, Hrynewycz Nadia M, Geoghegan Cara E, Mohan Shruthi, Jadczak Caroline N, Parrish James M, Jenkins Nathaniel W, Singh Kern
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Rush University Medical Center, Chicago, IL.
Clin Spine Surg. 2022 Apr 1;35(3):118-126. doi: 10.1097/BSD.0000000000001225.
This was a systematic review study.
This study aims to review current literature to determine the rates of complications in relation to spine surgery in ambulatory surgery centers (ASC).
Recent improvements in anesthesia, surgical techniques, and technological advances have facilitated a rise in the use of ASC. Despite the benefits and lower costs associated with ASCs, there is inconsistent reporting of complication rates.
This systematic review was completed utilizing the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA). Pertinent studies were identified through Embase and PubMed databases using the search string ((("ambulatory surgery center") AND "spine surgery") AND "complications"). Articles were excluded if they did not report outpatient surgery in an ASC, did not define complications, were in a language other than English, were non-human studies, or if the articles were classified as reviews, book chapters, single case reports, or small case series (≤10 patients). The primary outcome was the frequency of complications with respect to various categories.
Our query identified 150 articles. After filtering relevance by title, abstract, and full text, 22 articles were included. After accounting for 2 studies that were conducted on the same study sample, a total of 11,245 patients were analyzed in this study. The most recent study reported results from May 2019. While 5 studies did not list their surgical technique, studies reported techniques including open (6), minimally invasive surgery (2), endoscopic (4), microsurgery (1), and combined techniques (4). The following rates of complications were determined: cardiac 0.29% (3/1027), vascular 0.25% (18/7116), pulmonary 0.60% (11/1839), gastrointestinal 1.12% (2/179), musculoskeletal/spine/operative 0.59% (24/4053), urologic 0.80% (2/250), transient neurological 0.67% (31/4616), persistent neurological 0.61% (9/1479), pain related 0.57% (20/3479), and wound site 0.68% (28/4092).
After literature review, this is the first study to comprehensively analyze the current state of literature reporting on the complication profile of all ASC spine surgery procedures. The most common complications were gastrointestinal (1.12%) and the most infrequent were vascular (0.25%). Case reports varied significantly with regard to the type and rate of complications reported. This study provides complication profiles to assist surgeons in counseling patients on the most realistic expectations.
这是一项系统性综述研究。
本研究旨在回顾当前文献,以确定门诊手术中心(ASC)脊柱手术的并发症发生率。
麻醉、手术技术和技术进步的最新进展促进了ASC使用的增加。尽管ASC有诸多益处且成本较低,但并发症发生率的报告并不一致。
本系统性综述采用系统评价与Meta分析的首选报告项目(PRISMA)完成。通过Embase和PubMed数据库,使用检索词(((“门诊手术中心”)AND“脊柱手术”)AND“并发症”)识别相关研究。如果文章未报告在ASC进行的门诊手术、未定义并发症、非英文、非人体研究,或者文章被归类为综述、书籍章节、单病例报告或小病例系列(≤10例患者),则予以排除。主要结局是各类并发症的发生频率。
我们的检索共识别出150篇文章。通过标题、摘要和全文筛选相关性后,纳入了22篇文章。在考虑了2项对同一研究样本进行的研究后,本研究共分析了11245例患者。最新的研究报告了2019年5月的结果。虽然有5项研究未列出其手术技术,但报告的技术包括开放手术(6项)、微创手术(2项)、内镜手术(4项)、显微手术(1项)和联合技术(4项)。确定的并发症发生率如下:心脏并发症0.29%(3/1027),血管并发症0.25%(18/7116),肺部并发症0.60%(11/1839),胃肠道并发症1.12%(2/179),肌肉骨骼/脊柱/手术相关并发症0.59%(24/4053),泌尿系统并发症0.80%(2/250),短暂性神经并发症0.67%(31/4616),持续性神经并发症0.61%(9/1479),疼痛相关并发症0.57%(20/3479),伤口部位并发症0.68%(28/4092)。
经文献综述,这是第一项全面分析当前关于所有ASC脊柱手术并发症情况的文献报告现状的研究。最常见的并发症是胃肠道并发症(1.12%),最不常见的是血管并发症(0.25%)。关于报告的并发症类型和发生率,病例报告差异显著。本研究提供了并发症情况,以协助外科医生向患者提供最符合实际的预期建议。