From the Johns Hopkins University (K.G.-R., K.F., S.D.C., E.M.), Baltimore, MD; NYU Langone Health (L.Z.R., L.C.), New York; Washington University in St. Louis (R.N.), MO; Cleveland Clinic (D.O., K.M.), OH; and Biogen (W.C.-B.), Cambridge, MA.
Neurology. 2021 Aug 31;97(9):e881-e889. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000012362. Epub 2021 Jun 30.
To compare clinical and imaging features of multiple sclerosis (MS) severity between Black Americans (BAs) and White Americans (WAs) and to evaluate the role of socioeconomic status.
We compared BA and WA participants in the Multiple Sclerosis Partners Advancing Technology Health Solutions (MS PATHS) cohort with respect to MS characteristics, including self-reported disability, objective neurologic function assessments, and quantitative brain MRI measurements, after covariate adjustment (including education level, employment, or insurance as socioeconomic indicators). In a subgroup, we evaluated within-race, neighborhood-level indicators of socioeconomic status (SES) using 9-digit zip codes.
Of 1,214 BAs and 7,530 WAs with MS, BAs were younger, had lower education level, and were more likely to have Medicaid insurance or to be disabled or unemployed than WAs. BAs had worse self-reported disability (1.47-fold greater odds of severe vs mild disability, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.18, 1.86) and worse performances on tests of cognitive processing speed (-5.06 fewer correct, 95% CI -5.72, -4.41), walking (0.66 seconds slower, 95% CI 0.36, 0.96), and manual dexterity (2.11 seconds slower, 95% CI 1.69, 2.54). BAs had more brain MRI lesions and lower overall and gray matter brain volumes, including reduced thalamic (-0.77 mL, 95% CI -0.91, -0.64), cortical (-30.63 mL, 95% CI -35.93, -25.33), and deep (-1.58 mL, 95% CI -1.92, -1.23) gray matter volumes. While lower SES correlated with worse neuroperformance scores in WAs, this association was less clear in BAs.
We observed a greater burden of disease in BAs with MS relative to WAs with MS, despite adjustment for SES indicators. Beyond SES, future longitudinal studies should also consider roles of other societal constructs (e.g., systemic racism). Such studies will be important for identifying prognostic factors; developing optimal treatment strategies among BAs with MS is warranted.
比较黑种美国人和白种美国人多发性硬化症(MS)严重程度的临床和影像学特征,并评估社会经济地位的作用。
我们比较了多发性硬化症伙伴推进技术健康解决方案(MS PATHS)队列中的黑种美国人和白种美国人参与者,比较了包括自我报告的残疾、客观神经功能评估和定量脑 MRI 测量在内的 MS 特征,同时进行了协变量调整(包括教育程度、就业或保险等社会经济指标)。在一个亚组中,我们使用 9 位邮政编码评估了种族内的社会经济地位(SES)邻里水平指标。
在 1214 名黑种美国人和 7530 名白种美国人 MS 患者中,黑种美国人比白种美国人更年轻,教育程度更低,更有可能拥有医疗补助保险,或者残疾或失业。黑种美国人的自我报告残疾更严重(严重残疾的几率是轻度残疾的 1.47 倍,95%置信区间[CI] 1.18,1.86),认知处理速度测试的表现更差(5.06 个错误,95% CI 5.72,4.41),行走速度(慢 0.66 秒,95% CI 0.36,0.96)和手灵巧度(慢 2.11 秒,95% CI 1.69,2.54)。黑种美国人的脑 MRI 病变更多,整体和灰质脑容量更低,包括丘脑(-0.77 mL,95% CI -0.91,-0.64)、皮质(-30.63 mL,95% CI -35.93,-25.33)和深部(-1.58 mL,95% CI -1.92,-1.23)灰质体积减少。虽然较低的 SES 与白种美国人的神经功能评分较差相关,但在黑种美国人中,这种关联不太明显。
尽管调整了 SES 指标,但我们观察到黑种美国人多发性硬化症的疾病负担比白种美国人更重。除 SES 外,未来的纵向研究还应考虑其他社会结构(如系统性种族主义)的作用。这些研究对于确定预后因素很重要;有必要为黑种美国人多发性硬化症制定最佳治疗策略。