University of Michigan School of Social Work1080 S. University, Ann Arbor, MI, 48109-1106, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2021 Aug;283:114133. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2021.114133. Epub 2021 Jun 18.
As part of an ongoing participatory action research project initiated following the 2011 Great East Japan Disaster to improve disaster policies and responses, this study examines social factors and processes that affect women's well-being in and after disasters. Using PhotoVoice methodology, the project has engaged women affected by the Great East Japan Disaster in participatory assessment and analysis over the last ten years. Begun in three sites in June 2011, the project is currently operating in seven locations: four in the coastal areas affected by the tsunami in the Iwate and Miyagi prefectures; two in Fukushima Prefecture; and one in the Tokyo Metropolitan Area, where the largest number of out-of-prefecture evacuees reside. Participating members, recruited in collaboration with local NGOs, are women affected by the disaster aged from in their 20s to over 70 years. They take photographs of their lives and attend facilitated group discussions on an ongoing basis. Participatory analysis of their photographs and narratives by members and group facilitators (including the author) uses the analytical approach of grounded theory's open and focused coding with constant comparison. The analysis identifies various ways the disaster affected women, compromising their livelihood, safety, and well-being. It reveals an interconnection between the evacuation of children and women of reproductive age, loss of employment in the female-dominated occupational sectors, and increased dependent care responsibilities, which in turn compromises women's financial and emotional well-being. The analysis also elucidates the gendered division of labor in private and public spheres, shortages of maternal and infant health care, and gender-based violence in the post-disaster context. Notably, many of these issues and connections correspond to known social determinants of health disparities. The study findings add a valuable but often neglected local perspective and call for increased policy attention to eliminating gender disparities in disasters.
作为 2011 年东日本大地震后发起的一项旨在改善灾害政策和应对措施的持续参与式行动研究项目的一部分,本研究考察了影响妇女在灾害中和灾害后的福祉的社会因素和过程。该项目使用照片声音方法,在过去十年中让受东日本大地震影响的妇女参与参与式评估和分析。该项目于 2011 年 6 月在三个地点启动,目前在七个地点开展:四个在岩手县和宫城县受海啸影响的沿海地区;两个在福岛县;一个在东京都,那里居住着最多的外地疏散人员。参与成员是在当地非政府组织的合作下招募的,年龄在 20 多岁到 70 多岁之间,受灾害影响的妇女。她们拍摄自己生活的照片,并定期参加小组讨论。成员和小组协调员(包括作者)对她们的照片和叙述进行参与式分析,使用扎根理论的开放式和聚焦式编码与不断比较的分析方法。分析确定了灾害对妇女的各种影响方式,危及她们的生计、安全和福祉。它揭示了儿童和育龄妇女的疏散、女性主导的职业部门就业机会的丧失以及增加的依赖护理责任之间的相互联系,这反过来又危及妇女的经济和情感福祉。分析还阐明了公私领域的性别分工、母婴保健的短缺以及灾后的性别暴力。值得注意的是,其中许多问题和联系与已知的健康差异的社会决定因素相对应。该研究结果增加了一个有价值但往往被忽视的地方视角,并呼吁增加政策关注,以消除灾害中的性别差距。