School of Environmental and Geographical Sciences, University of Nottingham Malaysia, Malaysia.
Fluvial Dynamics Research Group, University of Lleida, E25198 Lleida, Catalonia, Spain; Forest Science and Technology Centre of Catalonia, E25280 Solsona, Catalonia, Spain.
Sci Total Environ. 2021 Nov 10;794:148686. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.148686. Epub 2021 Jun 25.
A major programme of dam building is underway in many of the world's tropical countries. This raises the question of whether existing research is sufficient to fully understand the impacts of dams on tropical river systems. This paper provides a systematic review of what is known about the impacts of dams on river flows, sediment dynamics and geomorphic processes in tropical rivers. The review was conducted using the SCOPUS® and Web of Science® databases, with papers analysed to look for temporal and geographic patterns in published work, assess the approaches used to help understand dam impacts, and assess the nature and magnitude of impacts on the flow regimes and geomorphology ('hydromorphology') of tropical rivers. As part of the review, a meta-analysis was used to compare key impacts across different climate regions. Although research on tropical rivers remains scarce, existing work is sufficient to allow us to draw some very broad, general conclusions about the nature of hydromorphic change: tropical dams have resulted in reductions in flow variability, lower flood peaks, reductions in sediment supply and loads, and complex geomorphic adjustments that include both channel incision and aggradation at different times and downstream distances. At this general level, impacts are consistent with those observed in other climate regions. However, studies are too few and variable in their focus to determine whether some of the more specific aspects of change observed in tropical rivers (e.g. time to reach a new, adjusted state, and downstream recovery distance) differ consistently from those in other regions. The review helps stress the need for research that incorporates before-after comparisons of flow and geomorphic conditions, and for the wider application of tools available now for assessing hydromorphic change. Very few studies have considered hydromorphic processes when designing flow operational policies for tropical dams.
在世界上许多热带国家,正在进行一项重大的水坝建设计划。这就提出了一个问题,即现有的研究是否足以充分了解大坝对热带河流系统的影响。本文对已知的大坝对热带河流的水流、泥沙动态和地貌过程的影响进行了系统回顾。该综述使用了 SCOPUS®和 Web of Science®数据库进行,对论文进行了分析,以寻找发表作品中的时间和地理模式,评估用于帮助理解大坝影响的方法,并评估对水流和地貌形态(“水形态学”)的影响的性质和规模热带河流。作为综述的一部分,使用荟萃分析比较了不同气候区的关键影响。尽管关于热带河流的研究仍然很少,但现有的工作足以让我们对水形态变化的性质得出一些非常广泛、一般的结论:热带大坝导致水流变化减少,洪峰降低,泥沙供应和负荷减少,以及复杂的地貌调整,包括不同时间和下游距离的渠道侵蚀和淤积。在这个一般水平上,影响与在其他气候区观察到的影响一致。然而,研究太少且重点不同,无法确定在热带河流中观察到的一些更具体的变化方面(例如达到新的、调整后的状态的时间和下游恢复距离)是否与其他地区一致。该综述有助于强调需要进行研究,将水流和地貌条件的前后对比纳入其中,并更广泛地应用现有的评估水形态变化的工具。很少有研究在为热带水坝设计水流运行政策时考虑水形态过程。