El Rhalete Abdelilah, Rhazi Inas, Bensaid Amine, Diass Soufiane, Kaouini Abderrahim, Ounci Essaad, Abdi Mohammed, Maarad Mohammed, Babouh Choukri, Alami Zineb, Abda Naima, Bkiyer Houssam, Housni Brahim
Department of Intensive Care Unit, Mohammed VI University Hospital, Oujda, Morocco.
Faculty of Medicine and Pharmacy, Mohammed 1st University, Oujda, Morocco.
Ann Med Surg (Lond). 2021 Jul;67:102514. doi: 10.1016/j.amsu.2021.102514. Epub 2021 Jun 25.
COVID-19 is a new disease that appeared in December 2019. Millions of people have been infected and died from this infection. Until today, the pathophysiology and treatment of this infection remain unknown, but a lot of studies are trying to solve the mystery. The trail of inflammation remains the most convincing, especially the Interleukin 6 (IL-6) which could play an important role in a reaction cascade leading to a cytokine storm. According to studies, although few in number, the Tociluzimab (TCZ), which is an anti-IL6, could prevent or even suppress this storm, leading to a less severe clinical state of the disease and a faster recovery. This could decrease the use of oxygen, avoid the risk of intubation and mortality.
This single-center retrospective observational case review brought together 557 COVID-19 seriously ill patients (pulmonary involvement> 25% + SatOAA <90%) admitted to the intensive care unit of our university hospital from March 1, 2020 to February 28, 2021. They were divided into 2 groups a Tociluzimab group (TCZ group) and a Non Tociluzimab group (NON TCZ) to facilitate the comparison. The aim of the study was to compare the length of hospital stay, the use of mechanical ventilation and the mortality in the TCZ group versus the NON TCZ group.
The average age of our patients was 62,05 years (±13.51) and 62.61 years (±16.33) respectively in the TCZ versus NON TCZ group. 76 (76%) were men while 24 were women (24%) in the TCZ group; and there was 313 (68.49%) men and 144 (31.51%) women in the NON TCZ group. Their average BMI was 28 kg/m2 (±4.52) in the TCZ group versus 27.89 kg/m2 (±4.73) in the NON TCZ group. Among them, the TCZ group included 38 (38%) diabetic patients, 38 hypertensive (38%), 12 heart disease (12%) and 2 chronic renal failure (2%), while the NON TCZ group regrouped 35 (7.65%) diabetics, 33 (7.22%) hypertensive, 12 heart disease (2.67%), and 5 chronic renal failure (1.09%) patients. The mean time to consultation of patients was almost similar in the two groups: 8.86 (±7,28) days for TCZ and 8.83 (±7,03) days for NON TCZ group. The mean length of ICU hospital stay was 9 days (4,94) for the TCZ group and 8,75 days (4,73) for the other one. The saturation at admission was at 74.92% (10.45) for the TCZ group ranging from 40% to 92%, and at 73,56% for the NON TCZ group. Lung damage from COVID-19 was extensive in 12%, severe in 32%, and critical in 56% of TCZ group enrolled cases. Meanwhile it was extensive in 23.63%, severe in 41,35%, and critical in 35,01% of the NON TCZ group. The biological findings found average of white blood cells at 12256/12082 e/mm, lymphocytes at 761/842 e/mm, CRP at 181/199 mg/L, ferritin at 1747/528 μg/L, and fibrinogen at 6.92/6.27 g/L for the TCZ group versus NON TCZ group. Medical care was based on isolation, oxygenotherapy, azithromycin, vitamin C, zinc, vitamin D, salicylic acid, dexamethasone followed with methylprednisolone, and anticoagulation for all hospitalized patients. The TCZ group received at least 1 course of Tociluzimab dosed at 400 mg (2 patients received 2 doses and 1 patient received 3 doses). The indication of a Tociluzimab course in our department was based on a set of arguments: an increase in oxygen requirements, a progression of lesions on chest-computed tomography and an increase in inflammation markers including IL-6, CRP, ferritin, fibrinogen, and a decrease in the percentage of lymphocytes. The invasive mechanical ventilation was indicated for 4 (4%) patients in the TCZ group versus 192 (42,01%) in the NON TCZ. Among the 100 patients included in our cohort in the TCZ group, 40% died in intensive care unit and 60% had a favorable evolution with a decrease of the biological markers of inflammation. However, in the NON TCZ group, 197 (43,10%) passed away.
The use of Tociluzimab in ICU patients with severe COVID-19 pneumonia did not contribute to a significant difference in the reduction of hospital stay. However, the invasive mechanical ventilation was less needed in patients receiving Tociluzimab than the others. Moreover, there was a mortality benefit associated with the use of Tociluzimab, but only before 10 days of hospitalization.
新型冠状病毒肺炎(COVID-19)是2019年12月出现的一种新疾病。数百万人已感染此病毒并因此死亡。直至今日,这种感染的病理生理学和治疗方法仍不明确,但许多研究正在试图解开这个谜团。炎症线索仍然是最有说服力的,尤其是白细胞介素6(IL-6),它可能在导致细胞因子风暴的反应级联中起重要作用。据研究,虽然数量不多,但抗IL-6药物托珠单抗(TCZ)可以预防甚至抑制这种风暴,使疾病的临床状态不那么严重,并加快康复速度。这可以减少氧气的使用,避免插管风险和死亡。
本单中心回顾性观察病例研究收集了2020年3月1日至2021年2月28日入住我校医院重症监护病房的557例COVID-19重症患者(肺部受累>25% + 动脉血氧饱和度<90%)。他们被分为两组,即托珠单抗组(TCZ组)和非托珠单抗组(NON TCZ组),以便于比较。本研究的目的是比较TCZ组和NON TCZ组的住院时间、机械通气的使用情况和死亡率。
我们患者的平均年龄在TCZ组和NON TCZ组分别为62.05岁(±13.51)和62.61岁(±16.33)。TCZ组中76例(76%)为男性,24例(24%)为女性;NON TCZ组中有313例(68.49%)男性和144例(31.51%)女性。TCZ组的平均体重指数为28 kg/m²(±4.52),NON TCZ组为27.89 kg/m²(±4.73)。其中,TCZ组包括38例(38%)糖尿病患者、38例高血压患者(38%)、12例心脏病患者(12%)和2例慢性肾衰竭患者(2%),而NON TCZ组分别为35例(7.65%)糖尿病患者、33例(7.22%)高血压患者、12例心脏病患者(2.67%)和5例慢性肾衰竭患者(1.09%)。两组患者的平均就诊时间几乎相似:TCZ组为8.86(±7.28)天,NON TCZ组为8.83(±7.03)天。TCZ组在重症监护病房的平均住院时间为9天(4.94),另一组为8.75天(4.73)。TCZ组入院时的血氧饱和度为74.92%(10.45),范围为40%至92%,NON TCZ组为73.56%。在TCZ组登记的病例中,12%的患者因COVID-19导致的肺损伤广泛,32%严重,56%危急。与此同时,NON TCZ组中23.63%的患者肺损伤广泛,41.35%严重,35.01%危急。与NON TCZ组相比,TCZ组的生物学检查结果显示白细胞平均为12256/12082 e/mm,淋巴细胞为761/842 e/mm,C反应蛋白为181/199 mg/L,铁蛋白为1747/528 μg/L,纤维蛋白原为6.92/6.27 g/L。所有住院患者的医疗护理均基于隔离、氧疗、阿奇霉素、维生素C、锌、维生素D、水杨酸、地塞米松继以甲泼尼龙以及抗凝治疗。TCZ组至少接受了1个疗程的托珠单抗治疗,剂量为400 mg(2例患者接受了2剂,1例患者接受了3剂)。我们科室使用托珠单抗疗程的指征基于一系列因素:氧需求增加、胸部计算机断层扫描上病变进展以及炎症标志物增加(包括IL-6、C反应蛋白、铁蛋白、纤维蛋白原),以及淋巴细胞百分比降低。TCZ组有4例(4%)患者需要有创机械通气,而NON TCZ组有192例(42.01%)。在我们队列中的TCZ组100例患者中,40%在重症监护病房死亡,60%病情好转,炎症生物学标志物下降。然而,在NON TCZ组中,197例(43.10%)死亡。
在患有严重COVID-19肺炎的重症监护病房患者中使用托珠单抗,在缩短住院时间方面没有显著差异。然而,接受托珠单抗治疗的患者比其他患者更少需要有创机械通气。此外,使用托珠单抗有死亡率获益,但仅在住院10天之前。