Notaro Eliza, Pascoe Vanessa L, Hippe Daniel S, Lachance Kristina, Shinohara Michi M, DeNiro Katherine L
Division of Dermatology, Department of Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States.
Department of Dermatology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, MA, United States.
Int J Womens Dermatol. 2020 Nov 5;7(3):270-275. doi: 10.1016/j.ijwd.2020.10.006. eCollection 2021 Jun.
Sexual harassment (SH) includes unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and hostile conduct that targets someone based on gender and overlaps with some types of sexual assault (SA). SH/SA in health care can occur between providers or between patient and provider. Most studies of SH in medicine focus on SH perpetrated by one health care provider against another, with very few studies examining SH from patient to provider.
This study aimed to describe the prevalence and impact of SH/SA from patient to provider, with a particular focus on SH/SA experienced by dermatologists and trainees.
An anonymous electronic survey was sent to professional listservs and an online forum, which included representatives from multiple institutions, practice settings, and medical specialties. Trainees and dermatologists were targeted particularly.
A total of 330 complete responses were included. In all, 83% of respondents reported experiencing SH from a patient. SH from a patient was more frequently reported by women compared with men (94% vs. 52%; = .001). Behaviors consistent with SA were experienced by 31% of respondents and were more frequently experienced by women (35% vs. 15%; = .001). Women were more likely to report that patient-to-provider SH contributed to burnout (33% of women vs. 9% of men; = .002). Female trainees were significantly more likely to have experienced SH compared with female attendings within the past year (94 of 110 trainees [86%] vs. 83 of 127 attendings [65%]; = .001). There was no significant difference in the proportion of women reporting ever experiencing SH when comparing dermatology and nondermatology specialties.
The limitations of this study include the relatively small sample size, oversampling of trainees, and a gender-biased sample.
Patient-to-provider SH/SA is widespread, particularly among women and trainees, and may have a significant impact on burnout.
性骚扰(SH)包括不受欢迎的性侵犯、性要求以及基于性别针对某人的敌意行为,并且与某些类型的性攻击(SA)存在重叠。医疗保健中的性骚扰/性攻击可能发生在医护人员之间,也可能发生在患者与医护人员之间。大多数医学领域关于性骚扰的研究聚焦于一名医护人员对另一名医护人员实施的性骚扰,很少有研究考察患者对医护人员的性骚扰。
本研究旨在描述患者对医护人员性骚扰/性攻击的发生率及影响,尤其关注皮肤科医生及其实习生所经历的此类情况。
向专业邮件列表和一个在线论坛发送了一份匿名电子调查问卷,其中包括来自多个机构、执业环境和医学专业的代表。特别针对实习生和皮肤科医生。
共纳入330份完整回复。总体而言,83%的受访者报告曾遭受患者的性骚扰。与男性相比,女性报告遭受患者性骚扰的比例更高(94%对52%;P = 0.001)。31%的受访者经历过与性攻击相符的行为,女性经历此类行为的比例更高(35%对15%;P = 0.001)。女性更有可能报告患者对医护人员的性骚扰导致职业倦怠(33%的女性对9%的男性;P = 0.002)。在过去一年中,女性实习生遭受性骚扰的可能性显著高于女性主治医生(110名实习生中有94名[86%],127名主治医生中有83名[65%];P = 0.001)。在比较皮肤科和非皮肤科专业时,报告曾遭受性骚扰的女性比例没有显著差异。
本研究的局限性包括样本量相对较小、实习生过度抽样以及样本存在性别偏差。
患者对医护人员的性骚扰/性攻击很普遍,尤其是在女性和实习生中,并且可能对职业倦怠产生重大影响。