Gude Zachary, Adamson Justus, Kirkpatrick John P, Giles William
Radiation Therapy, Duke University, Durham, USA.
Radiation Oncology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, USA.
Cureus. 2021 Jun 2;13(6):e15399. doi: 10.7759/cureus.15399. eCollection 2021 Jun.
Brain metastases are a common complication for patients diagnosed with cancer. As stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) becomes a more prevalent treatment option for patients with many brain metastases, further research is required to better characterize the ability of SRS to treat large numbers of metastases (≥4) and the impact on normal brain tissue and, ultimately, neurocognition and quality of life (QOL). This study serves first as an evaluation of the feasibility of hippocampal avoidance for SRS patients, specifically receiving single-isocenter multitarget treatments (SIMT) planned with volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT). Second, this study analyzes the effects of standard-definition (SD) multileaf collimators (MLCs) (5 mm width) on plan quality and hippocampal avoidance. The 40 patients enrolled in this Institutional Review Board (IRB)-approved study had between four and 10 brain metastases and were treated with SIMT using VMAT. From the initial 40 patients, eight hippocampi across seven patients had hippocampal doses exceeding the maximum biologically effective dose (BED) constraint given by RTOG 0933. With the addition of upper constraints in the optimization objectives and one arc angle adjustment in one patient plan, four out of seven patient plans were able to meet the maximum hippocampal BED constraint, avoiding five out of eight total hippocampi at risk. High-definition (HD) MLCs allowed for an average decrease of 29% ± 23% (p= 0.007) in the maximum BED delivered to all eight hippocampi at risk. The ability to meet dose constraints depended on the distance between the hippocampus and the nearest planning target volume (PTV). Meeting the maximum hippocampal BED constraint in re-optimized plans was equally likely with the use of SD-MLCs (five out of eight hippocampi at risk were avoided) but resulted in increased dose to normal tissue volumes (23.67% ± 16.3% increase in V50%[cc] of normal brain tissue, i.e., brain volume subtracted by the total PTV) when compared to the HD-MLC re-optimized plans. Comparing the effects of SD-MLCs on plans not optimized for hippocampal avoidance resulted in increases of 48.2% ± 32.2% (p=0.0056), 31.5% ± 16.3% (p= 0.024), and 16.7% ± 8.5% (p= 0.022) in V20%[cc], V50%[cc], and V75%[cc], respectively, compared to the use of HD-MLCs. The conformity index changed significantly neither when plans were optimized for hippocampal avoidance nor when SD-MLC leaves were used for treatment. In plans not optimized for hippocampal avoidance, mean hippocampal dose increased with the use of SD-MLCs by 38.0% ± 37.5% (p= 0.01). However, the use of SD-MLCs did not result in an increased number of hippocampi at risk.
脑转移是癌症患者常见的并发症。随着立体定向放射外科(SRS)成为治疗多发脑转移患者越来越普遍的治疗选择,需要进一步研究以更好地描述SRS治疗大量转移灶(≥4个)的能力以及对正常脑组织的影响,并最终明确其对神经认知和生活质量(QOL)的影响。本研究首先评估了SRS患者避免海马区受照的可行性,特别是接受采用容积调强弧形放疗(VMAT)计划的单等中心多靶点治疗(SIMT)的患者。其次,本研究分析了标准定义(SD)多叶准直器(MLC)(5毫米宽度)对计划质量和海马区避免受照的影响。这项经机构审查委员会(IRB)批准的研究纳入了40例患者,他们有4至10个脑转移灶,并接受了使用VMAT的SIMT治疗。在最初的40例患者中,7例患者的8个海马区海马剂量超过了RTOG 0933给出的最大生物等效剂量(BED)限制。通过在优化目标中增加上限约束以及对1例患者计划进行1个弧角调整,7例患者计划中有4例能够满足最大海马区BED限制,避免了8个有风险的海马区中的5个。高清(HD)MLC使所有8个有风险的海马区所接受的最大BED平均降低了29%±23%(p = 0.007)。满足剂量限制的能力取决于海马区与最近的计划靶区(PTV)之间的距离。在重新优化的计划中,使用SD-MLC同样有可能满足最大海马区BED限制(避免了8个有风险的海马区中的5个),但与HD-MLC重新优化的计划相比,会导致正常组织体积的剂量增加(正常脑组织V50%[cc]增加23.67%±16.3%,即脑体积减去总PTV)。比较SD-MLC对未针对海马区避免受照进行优化的计划所产生的影响,与使用HD-MLC相比,V20%[cc]、V50%[cc]和V75%[cc]分别增加了48.2%±32.2%(p = 0.0056)、31.5%±16.3%(p = 0.024)和16.7%±8.5%(p = 0.022)。无论是针对海马区避免受照进行优化的计划,还是使用SD-MLC叶片进行治疗时,适形指数均无显著变化。在未针对海马区避免受照进行优化的计划中,使用SD-MLC时海马区平均剂量增加了38.0%±37.5%(p = 0.01)。然而,使用SD-MLC并未导致有风险的海马区数量增加。