Garza Marcela, Graetz Dylan E, Kaye Erica C, Ferrara Gia, Rodriguez Mario, Soberanis Vásquez Dora Judith, Méndez Aceituno Alejandra, Antillon-Klussmann Federico, Gattuso Jami S, Mandrell Belinda N, Baker Justin N, Rodriguez-Galindo Carlos, Agulnik Asya
Department of Global Pediatric Medicine, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, TN, United States.
Division of Quality of Life and Palliative Care, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, TN, United States.
Front Oncol. 2021 Jun 23;11:660051. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2021.660051. eCollection 2021.
Children with cancer are at high risk for clinical deterioration and subsequent mortality. Pediatric Early Warning Systems (PEWS) have proven to reduce the frequency of clinical deterioration in hospitalized patients. This qualitative study evaluates provider perspectives on the impact of PEWS on quality of care during deterioration events in a high-resource and a resource-limited setting.
We conducted semi-structured interviews with 83 healthcare staff (nurses, pediatricians, oncology fellows, and intensivists) involved in recent deterioration events at two pediatric oncology hospitals of different resource levels: St. Jude Children's Research Hospital (SJCRH; n = 42) and Unidad Nacional de Oncología Pediátrica (UNOP; n = 41). Interviews were conducted in the participant's native language (English or Spanish), translated into English, and transcribed. Transcripts were coded and analyzed inductively.
Providers discussed both positive and negative perspectives of clinical deterioration events. Content analysis revealed "teamwork," "experience with deterioration," "early awareness," and "effective communication" as themes associated with positive perception of events, which contributed to patient safety. Negative themes included "lack of communication," "inexperience with deterioration," "challenges with technology", "limited material resources," "false positive score," and "objective tool." Participants representing all disciplines across both institutions shared similar positive opinions. Negative opinions, however, differed between the two institutions, with providers at UNOP highlighting limited resources while those at SJCRH expressing concerns about technology misuse.
Providers that care for children with cancer find PEWS valuable to improve the quality of hospital care, regardless of hospital resource-level. Identified challenges, including inadequate critical care resources and challenges with technology, differ by hospital resource-level. These findings build on growing data demonstrating the positive impact of PEWS on quality of care and encourage wide dissemination of PEWS in clinical practice.
癌症患儿临床病情恶化及随后死亡的风险很高。儿科早期预警系统(PEWS)已被证明可降低住院患者临床病情恶化的频率。本定性研究评估了在资源丰富和资源有限的环境中,医疗服务提供者对PEWS在病情恶化事件期间对医疗质量影响的看法。
我们对参与近期不同资源水平的两家儿科肿瘤医院病情恶化事件的83名医护人员(护士、儿科医生、肿瘤学研究员和重症监护医生)进行了半结构化访谈:圣裘德儿童研究医院(SJCRH;n = 42)和国家儿科肿瘤学单位(UNOP;n = 41)。访谈以参与者的母语(英语或西班牙语)进行,翻译成英语并转录。对转录本进行编码并进行归纳分析。
医疗服务提供者讨论了临床病情恶化事件的积极和消极看法。内容分析揭示了“团队合作”、“病情恶化经验”、“早期意识”和“有效沟通”是与对事件的积极认知相关的主题,这些有助于患者安全。消极主题包括“沟通不畅”、“病情恶化经验不足”、“技术挑战”、“物质资源有限”、“假阳性评分”和“客观工具”。两个机构中代表所有学科的参与者都有相似的积极看法。然而,两个机构的消极看法有所不同,UNOP的医疗服务提供者强调资源有限,而SJCRH的医疗服务提供者则对技术滥用表示担忧。
无论医院资源水平如何,照顾癌症患儿的医疗服务提供者都认为PEWS对提高医院医疗质量很有价值。已确定的挑战,包括重症监护资源不足和技术挑战,因医院资源水平而异。这些发现基于越来越多的数据,这些数据证明了PEWS对医疗质量的积极影响,并鼓励在临床实践中广泛推广PEWS。