Manchester Clinical Reasoning Group, School of Medical Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, Biology and Health, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Salford Royal NHS Foundation Trust, Salford, UK.
Diagnosis (Berl). 2021 Jul 14;9(2):184-194. doi: 10.1515/dx-2021-0031.
There is consensus that clinical reasoning (CR) is crucial for increasing the value of diagnosis, medical decision-making and error reduction. These skills should be developed throughout medical education, starting with undergraduate study. International guidance provides principles for CR curricula but interventions to date, are short term in nature. In this report, we describe the creation of a longitudinal, spiral CR curriculum within a large UK medical school programme (2500 students). A working group drove systematic evidence-based reform of existing structures. We utilised recognised models for curriculum development and mapping, relating learning outcomes to competency frameworks. Application of multiple teaching methodologies, rooted in enquiry-based learning and reported in CR literature, encourage metacognition for information-processing and illness script development. Development of CR is emphasised with recurrent, progressive learning opportunities, each stage purposefully building upon previous experiences. Formative and summative assessment approaches to drive learning, encouraging students' ability to apply and articulate CR, is constructed via Miller's Prism of Clinical Competence. Implementation of pedagogy is contingent on faculty development. Whilst many clinicians practice sound CR, the ability to articulate it to students is often a novel skill. Engagement in faculty development was strengthened through cross-institutional recognition of teaching workload and flexibility of delivery. We report lessons learned from the implementation phase and plans for measuring impact.
人们普遍认为,临床推理(CR)对于提高诊断、医疗决策和减少错误的价值至关重要。这些技能应该在整个医学教育过程中培养,从本科学习开始。国际指南为 CR 课程提供了原则,但迄今为止的干预措施本质上是短期的。在本报告中,我们描述了在英国一所大型医学院计划(2500 名学生)中创建一个纵向、螺旋式 CR 课程。一个工作组推动了对现有结构的系统循证改革。我们利用了公认的课程开发和映射模型,将学习成果与能力框架联系起来。应用多种教学方法,根植于基于探究的学习,并在 CR 文献中报告,鼓励信息处理和疾病脚本开发的元认知。通过多次、渐进的学习机会强调 CR 的发展,每个阶段都有意建立在前一个阶段的基础上。形成性和总结性评估方法来推动学习,鼓励学生应用和表达 CR 的能力,是通过 Miller 的临床能力棱镜来构建的。教学的实施取决于教师的发展。虽然许多临床医生都有合理的 CR 实践,但将其向学生表达出来的能力往往是一种新的技能。通过机构间对教学工作量的认可和教学方式的灵活性,加强了教师发展的参与。我们报告了实施阶段的经验教训和衡量影响的计划。