Improving carbohydrate utilization can contribute to sustainability of aquaculture. In order to explore the feedback mechanism of glucose homeostasis in fish, one control diet (25% carbohydrate and 40% protein), one relatively high carbohydrate diet named HG (42% carbohydrate and 40% protein), and one high dietary carbohydrate coupled with relatively low protein diet named HGP (42% carbohydrate and 25% protein) were fed to grass carp for 40 days. After the feeding trial, HG group impeded the food intake and growth performance of fish compared with the other two groups. Meanwhile, the serum glucose and insulin level were both significantly elevated under the condition of high carbohydrates intake when compared HG with control group. However, although no significant difference was observed in peripheral glucose or insulin between HG and HGP groups, fish fed with HGP diet increased growth performance and food intake compared with the HG group. Gene expression data indicated that fish selectively regulated the expressions of the cerebral anorexigenic genes (cart and pomc) to adapt to the HG and HGP intake. Therefore, the HGP diet with high carbohydrate and low protein was more suitable for grass carp feeding and growth when compared with the other two diets, possibly because the diet composition was closer to the natural food of this fish. In addition, the serum leptin level was highly consistent with changes in food intake and anorexigenic gene expressions when comparing the three experimental diets, indicating that leptin might be the key to mediate the feedback regulation of carbohydrates intake on food intake and appetite in fish.