Yusuf Lamia
Dr. Lamia Yusuf Associate Professor Gynae & Obs, Pak Red Crescent Medical College, Lahore, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2021 Jul-Aug;37(4):1206-1210. doi: 10.12669/pjms.37.4.4005.
Assessment of skills is an important part of medical education. The objective was to find out how students perceive their learning after being assessed through OSCE.
It was a mixed convergent parallel study. The study was carried out in the gynaecology department of a private medical college in Lahore. Five groups of final year students posted for rotation in gynae wards were included in this study. Each group comprised of 18 students. They were exposed to OSCE once daily. After completion of one month, students were given a feedback questionnaire (developed and validated by medical educationists) and a focus group discussion was carried out. Eight participants were selected from each group randomly and interviews were recorded. Interviews were transcribed verbatim.
Quantitative data calculated by SPSS 21 and results were calculated as frequencies. Qualitative analysis was based on word frequency count and thematic analysis was followed. Almost 65.2% of the student Shows agreement to the response that OSCE should be part of internal assessments. Whereas 15% shows disagreement and 9% remain neutral. The themes extracted after interviews were, better assessment tool, exam fear, knowledge, confidence and change learning style. thus, triangulating the data. The outcome measured was the result of the final professional of obstetrics and gynaecology year 2017-2018 batch. The success rate was 100% in gynae/obs and one student was able to get a distinction.
Students perceived OSCE as a better assessment tool that increased their knowledge and confidence level. Thus, they were an opinion that OSCE should be part of examinations held in college.
技能评估是医学教育的重要组成部分。目的是了解学生在通过客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)进行评估后如何看待他们的学习情况。
这是一项混合收敛平行研究。该研究在拉合尔一所私立医学院的妇科进行。纳入了五组在妇科病房轮转的最后一年学生。每组由18名学生组成。他们每天接受一次OSCE。一个月结束后,给学生发放一份反馈问卷(由医学教育工作者制定并验证),并进行了焦点小组讨论。从每组中随机挑选8名参与者,并记录访谈内容。访谈逐字转录。
由SPSS 21计算定量数据,并将结果计算为频率。定性分析基于词频统计,并采用主题分析。几乎65.2%的学生同意OSCE应成为内部评估的一部分这一回答。而15%表示不同意,9%保持中立。访谈后提取的主题有,更好的评估工具、考试恐惧、知识、信心和学习方式的改变。因此,对数据进行了三角测量。所测量的结果是2017 - 2018届妇产科专业期末考试的结果。妇科/产科的成功率为100%,一名学生获得了优异成绩。
学生认为OSCE是一种更好的评估工具,提高了他们的知识和信心水平。因此,他们认为OSCE应该成为学院考试的一部分。