Frazier S Barron, Walls Claci, Jain Sweeti, Plemmons Gregory, Johnson David P
Divisions of Emergency Medicine
General Pediatrics.
Pediatrics. 2021 Sep;148(3). doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-014597. Epub 2021 Aug 3.
Bronchiolitis is a leading cause of pediatric hospitalization in the United States, resulting in significant morbidity and health care resource use. Despite American Academy of Pediatrics recommendations against obtaining chest radiographs (CXRs) for bronchiolitis, variation in care continues. Historically, clinical practice guidelines and educational campaigns have had mixed success in reducing unnecessary CXR use. Our aim was to reduce CXR use for children <2 years with a primary diagnosis of bronchiolitis, regardless of emergency department (ED) disposition or preexisting conditions, from 42.1% to <15% of encounters by March 2020.
A multidisciplinary team was created at our institution in 2012 to standardize bronchiolitis care. Given success with higher reliability interventions in asthma, similar interventions affecting workflow were subsequently pursued with bronchiolitis, starting in 2017, by using quality improvement science methods. The primary outcome was the percent of bronchiolitis encounters with a CXR. The balancing measure was return visits within 72 hours to the ED. Statistical process control charts were used to monitor and analyze data obtained from an internally created dashboard.
From 2012 to 2020, our hospital had 12 120 bronchiolitis encounters. Preimplementation baseline revealed a mean of 42.1% for CXR use. Low reliability interventions, like educational campaigns, resulted in unsustained effects on CXR use. Higher reliability interventions were associated with sustained reductions to 23.3% and 18.9% over the last 4 years. There was no change in ED return visits.
High-reliability workflow redesign was more effective in translating American Academy of Pediatrics recommendations into sustained practice than educational campaigns.
在美国,细支气管炎是儿童住院治疗的主要原因,会导致严重的发病率以及医疗资源的大量使用。尽管美国儿科学会建议不要为细支气管炎患儿进行胸部X光检查(CXR),但医疗护理的差异依然存在。从历史来看,临床实践指南和教育活动在减少不必要的胸部X光检查使用方面成效不一。我们的目标是,到2020年3月,将初次诊断为细支气管炎的2岁以下儿童的胸部X光检查使用率,无论其急诊科处置情况或既往病史如何,从42.1%降至就诊次数的15%以下。
2012年,我们机构组建了一个多学科团队,以规范细支气管炎的护理。鉴于在哮喘治疗中采用更高可靠性干预措施取得了成功,自2017年起,我们随后采用质量改进科学方法,对细支气管炎采取了类似的影响工作流程的干预措施。主要结果是进行胸部X光检查的细支气管炎就诊病例百分比。平衡指标是72小时内返回急诊科复诊的情况。使用统计过程控制图来监测和分析从内部创建的仪表板获取的数据。
2012年至2020年,我院有12120例细支气管炎就诊病例。实施前的基线显示,胸部X光检查的平均使用率为42.1%。像教育活动这样的低可靠性干预措施,对胸部X光检查的使用产生了难以持续的影响。在过去4年中,更高可靠性的干预措施使使用率持续降至23.3%和18.9%。急诊科复诊情况没有变化。
与教育活动相比,高可靠性的工作流程重新设计在将美国儿科学会的建议转化为持续的临床实践方面更有效。