Department of Neurology, Antalya Training and Research Hospital, Antalya, Turkey.
Ideggyogy Sz. 2021 Jul 30;74(7-08):257-265. doi: 10.18071/isz.74.0257.
Many systemic problems arise due to the side effects of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) used in epilepsy patients. Among these adverse effects are low bone mineral density and increased fracture risk due to long-term AED use. Although various studies have supported this association with increased risk in recent years, the length of this process has not been precisely defined and there is no clear consensus on bone density scanning, intervals of screening, and the subject of calcium and vitamin D supplementation. In this study, in accordance with the most current recommendations, our applications and data, including the detection of possible bone mineralization disorders, treatment methods, and recommendations to prevent bone mineralization disorders, were evaluated in epilepsy patients who were followed up at our outpatient clinic. It was aimed to draw attention to the significance of management of bone metabolism carried out with appropriate protocols.
Epilepsy patients were followed up at the Antalya Training and Research Hospital Department of Neurology, Epilepsy Outpatient Clinic who were at high risk for osteoporosis (use of valproic acid [VPA] and enzyme-inducing drugs, using any AED for over 5 years, and postmenopausal women) and were evaluated using a screening protocol. According to this protocol, a total of 190 patients suspected of osteoporosis risk were retrospectively evaluated. Four patients were excluded from the study due to secondary osteoporosis.
Of the 186 patients who were included in the study, 97 (52.2%) were women and 89 (47.8%) were men. Prevalence of low bone mineral density (BMD) was 42%, in which osteoporosis was detected in 11.8% and osteopenia in 30.6% of the patients. Osteoporosis rate was higher at the young age group (18-45) and this difference was statistically significant (p=0.018). There was no significant difference between male and female sexes according to osteoporosis and osteopenia rates. Patients receiving polytherapy had higher osteoporosis rate and lower BMD compared to patients receiving monotherapy. Comparison of separate drug groups according to osteoporosis rate revealed that osteoporosis rate was highest in patient groups using VPA+ carbamazepine (CBZ) (29.4%) and VPA polytherapy (19.4%). Total of osteopenia and osteoporosis, or low BMD, was highest in VPA polytherapy (VPA+ non-enzyme-inducing AED [NEID]) and CBZ polytherapy (CBZ+NEID) groups, with rates of 58.3% and 55.1%, respectively. In addition, there was no significant difference between drug groups according to bone metabolism markers, vitamin D levels, and osteopenia-osteoporosis rates.
Assuming bone health will be affected at an early age in epilepsy patients, providing lifestyle and diet recommendations, avoiding polytherapy including VPA and CBZ when possible, and evaluating bone metabolism at regular intervals are actions that should be applied in routine practice.
抗癫痫药物(AEDs)在癫痫患者中的副作用会引发许多系统性问题。这些不良反应包括由于长期使用 AED 而导致的骨密度降低和骨折风险增加。尽管近年来各种研究都支持这种风险增加的关联,但这个过程的持续时间尚未精确界定,对于骨密度扫描、筛查间隔以及钙和维生素 D 补充的对象也没有明确的共识。在这项研究中,我们根据最新的建议和我们的应用和数据,包括可能的骨矿化障碍的检测、治疗方法以及预防骨矿化障碍的建议,对在我们的门诊接受随访的癫痫患者进行了评估。旨在引起对通过适当方案进行骨代谢管理的重视。
在安塔利亚培训和研究医院神经内科癫痫门诊,对有骨质疏松症高风险的癫痫患者(使用丙戊酸[VPA]和酶诱导药物、使用任何 AED 超过 5 年以及绝经后女性)进行了随访,并使用了筛查方案进行了评估。根据该方案,对 190 名疑似骨质疏松风险的患者进行了回顾性评估。由于继发性骨质疏松症,有 4 名患者被排除在研究之外。
在纳入研究的 186 名患者中,97 名(52.2%)为女性,89 名(47.8%)为男性。低骨密度(BMD)的患病率为 42%,其中骨质疏松症在 11.8%的患者中被检测到,骨量减少在 30.6%的患者中被检测到。骨质疏松症的发生率在年轻组(18-45 岁)较高,且差异具有统计学意义(p=0.018)。根据骨质疏松症和骨量减少的发生率,男女之间无显著差异。与接受单药治疗的患者相比,接受多药治疗的患者骨质疏松症发生率更高,BMD 更低。根据骨质疏松症发生率对单独药物组进行比较发现,使用 VPA+卡马西平(CBZ)(29.4%)和 VPA 多药治疗(19.4%)的患者骨质疏松症发生率最高。VPA 多药治疗(VPA+非酶诱导 AED [NEID])和 CBZ 多药治疗(CBZ+NEID)组的总骨质疏松症和骨量减少或低 BMD 发生率最高,分别为 58.3%和 55.1%。此外,药物组之间的骨代谢标志物、维生素 D 水平和骨质疏松症-骨量减少发生率无显著差异。
假设癫痫患者的骨健康会在早期受到影响,因此应提供生活方式和饮食建议,尽可能避免包括 VPA 和 CBZ 在内的多药治疗,并定期评估骨代谢情况。