Department of Thoracic Surgery, National Cancer Center/National Clinical Research Center for Cancer/Cancer Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, China.
Department of Medical Oncology, National Cancer Center/National Clinical Research Center for Cancer/Cancer Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, China.
Lancet Oncol. 2021 Sep;22(9):1265-1274. doi: 10.1016/S1470-2045(21)00333-8. Epub 2021 Aug 13.
BACKGROUND: Numerous ongoing trials are testing anti-PD-1-based or anti-PD-L1-based cancer treatment combinations. Understanding the toxicity profiles of treatment-related adverse events is essential. The aim of this study was to comprehensively investigate the incidences and profiles of treatment-related adverse events across different combination therapies. METHODS: We did a systematic review and meta-analysis comparing different chemotherapy, targeted therapy, immunotherapy, and radiotherapy combinations with PD-1 or PD-L1 inhibitors. We searched Pubmed, Embase, and Cochrane databases for articles published in English between Jan 1, 2000, and May 21, 2020, investigating globally approved PD-1 or PD-L1 inhibitor-based combination therapies. Only prospective trials reporting overall incidence or tabulated data of treatment-related adverse events were included. Trials investigating sequential therapies, comprising three or more classes of therapies, and enrolling less than ten patients were excluded. The primary outcomes were overall incidences and profiles for all-grade and grade 3 or higher treatment-related adverse events by random-effect models. Heterogeneity between studies was assessed with I statistics. The summary measures for main outcomes are incidences (95% CI). The 95% CI were calculated together with the incidence through a random-effects model with a logit transformation. The protocol is registered with PROSPERO (CRD42020189617). FINDINGS: We identified 2540 records, of which 161 studies (17 197 patients) met the inclusion criteria. The overall incidence of treatment-related adverse events in the chemotherapy combination was 97·7% (95% CI 96·4-98·5; I=75%) for all-grade adverse events and 68·3% (60·7-75·0; I=93%) for grade 3 or higher adverse events; in the targeted therapy combination was 94·5% (90·7-96·8; I=86%) for all-grade adverse events and 47·3% (37·3-57·5; I=93%) for grade 3 or higher adverse events; in the immunotherapy combination was 86·8% (80·9-91·1; I=94%) for all-grade adverse events and 35·9% (29·5-42·9; I=92%) for grade 3 or higher adverse events; and in the radiotherapy combination was 89·4% (69·0-96·9; I=74%) for all-grade adverse events and 12·4% (4·4-30·6; I=73%) for grade 3 or higher adverse events. For these four combination therapies, the most common all-grade adverse events were anaemia (45.4% [95% CI 32·4-59·1]), fatigue (34·3% [27·5-41·9]), fatigue (26·4% [19·2-35·2]), and dysphagia (30·0% [18·7-44·5]), respectively, and the most common grade 3 or higher adverse events were neutropenia (19·6% [13·5-27·7]), hypertension (9·3% [5·7-14·9]), lipase increased (7·2% [5·2-9·9]), and lymphopenia (10·3% [4·5-21·8]). All included randomised controlled trials had a low risk of bias. INTERPRETATION: Our study provides comprehensive data on treatment-related adverse events of different PD-1 or PD-L1 inhibitor-based combination therapies. Our results provide an essential reference of toxicity profiles of PD-1 or PD-L1 inhibitor-based combination therapies for clinicians in routine practice of cancer care. FUNDING: National Key Research and Development Programme, National Natural Science Foundation of China key program, National Natural Science Foundation of China general program, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences Initiative for Innovative Medicine, Beijing Municipal Science and Technology Commission, Non-profit Central Research Institute Fund.
背景:目前有许多正在进行的试验正在测试基于抗 PD-1 或抗 PD-L1 的癌症联合治疗方法。了解治疗相关不良反应的毒性特征至关重要。本研究旨在全面研究不同联合治疗方案中治疗相关不良反应的发生率和特征。
方法:我们进行了一项系统综述和荟萃分析,比较了不同的化疗、靶向治疗、免疫治疗和放射治疗联合 PD-1 或 PD-L1 抑制剂的情况。我们在 PubMed、Embase 和 Cochrane 数据库中搜索了 2000 年 1 月 1 日至 2020 年 5 月 21 日发表的全球批准的基于 PD-1 或 PD-L1 抑制剂的联合治疗试验。只有前瞻性试验报告了总体发生率或治疗相关不良反应的表格数据才被纳入。排除了研究顺序疗法(包含三种或更多种疗法)和纳入患者少于 10 例的试验。主要结局是通过随机效应模型评估所有级别和 3 级或更高治疗相关不良反应的总体发生率和特征。通过 I 统计量评估研究之间的异质性。主要结局的汇总指标是发生率(95%CI)。通过对数转换的随机效应模型,与发生率一起计算 95%CI。该方案在 PROSPERO(CRD42020189617)上注册。
发现:我们共确定了 2540 条记录,其中 161 项研究(17197 例患者)符合纳入标准。化疗联合治疗的治疗相关不良反应的总发生率为所有级别不良反应 97.7%(95%CI 96.4-98.5;I=75%),3 级或更高不良反应 68.3%(60.7-75.0;I=93%);靶向治疗联合治疗的所有级别不良反应为 94.5%(90.7-96.8;I=86%),3 级或更高不良反应为 47.3%(37.3-57.5;I=93%);免疫治疗联合治疗的所有级别不良反应为 86.8%(80.9-91.1;I=94%),3 级或更高不良反应为 35.9%(29.5-42.9;I=92%);放射治疗联合治疗的所有级别不良反应为 89.4%(69.0-96.9;I=74%),3 级或更高不良反应为 12.4%(4.4-30.6;I=73%)。对于这四种联合治疗方法,最常见的所有级别不良反应是贫血(45.4% [95%CI 32.4-59.1])、疲劳(34.3% [27.5-41.9])、疲劳(26.4% [19.2-35.2])和吞咽困难(30.0% [18.7-44.5]),最常见的 3 级或更高不良反应是中性粒细胞减少(19.6% [13.5-27.7])、高血压(9.3% [5.7-14.9])、脂肪酶升高(7.2% [5.2-9.9])和淋巴细胞减少(10.3% [4.5-21.8])。所有纳入的随机对照试验的偏倚风险均较低。
解释:本研究提供了不同 PD-1 或 PD-L1 抑制剂联合治疗方法的治疗相关不良反应的综合数据。我们的研究结果为临床医生在癌症治疗常规实践中提供了 PD-1 或 PD-L1 抑制剂联合治疗方法的毒性特征的重要参考。
资助:国家重点研发计划、国家自然科学基金重点项目、国家自然科学基金面上项目、中国医学科学院创新工程、北京市科学技术委员会、非营利性中央研究机构基金。
Int Immunopharmacol. 2020-10
Antibodies (Basel). 2025-7-11
Theranostics. 2025-5-9