Diendéré Eric Arnaud, Traoré Karim, Bernatas Jean-Jacques, Idogo Ouedan, Dao Abdoul Kader, Traoré Go Karim, Napon/Zongo P Delphine, Ouédraogo/Dioma Solange, Bognounou René, Diallo Ismael, Ouédraogo/Sondo Apoline Kongnimissom, Niamba Pascal Antoine
Eric Arnaud Diendéré is based at the Department of Internal Medicine, Bogodogo Teaching Hospital, and Medical association "SOS Médecins - Burkina Faso", Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso.
Karim Traoré is based at General Directorate of the Prison Security Guard/Ministry of Justice/Burkina Faso, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso.
Int J Prison Health. 2022 Jan 25;18(1):97-113. doi: 10.1108/IJPH-04-2021-0036. Epub 2021 Aug 13.
The purpose of this paper is to study the factors associated with the occurrence of diseases and beriberi among prisoners incarcerated in the two largest Remand and Correctional Facilities (RCF).
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: This was a cross-sectional descriptive and analytical study carried out from April 20 to May 19, 2017, in the RCFs of Ouagadougou and Bobo-Dioulasso. All prisoners who consulted and those referred to the health center by the health-care team were included in the study. Complaints and diagnosed diseases information were collected using the second version of the International Classification of Primary Care (ICPC-2). The authors used a logistic regression model to perform univariate and multivariate analyses.
Of the 1,004 prisoners from the two RCFs included in the study (32.6%), 966 (96%) were male. The median age was 31.6 years. The distribution of diseases diagnosed using the ICPC-2 showed a predominance of gastrointestinal tract, skin and respiratory tract diseases among 206 (19.3%), 188 (17.6%) and 184 (17.2%) prisoners, respectively. A total of 302 prisoners (30.1%) had clinical beriberi, and 80 prisoners (8%) were underweight. Being incarcerated for more than nine months was independently associated with a high risk of digestive and respiratory diseases as well as beriberi.
RESEARCH LIMITATIONS/IMPLICATIONS: This study highlighted higher frequencies of digestive, skin and respiratory complaints and diseases in the two largest detention centers in Burkina Faso. These diseases are variously related to age, penal status and length of incarceration. In addition, underweight and thiamin vitamin deficiency responsible for beriberi are more frequent in adult prisoners, those not attending school, convicted prisoners and those with a length of stay in detention of more than nine months. These concrete results should help define a strategy and priority actions needed to reduce morbidity in prisons.
The actions should include the intervention of specialists in the field of common diseases in prisons, the improvement of individual hygiene conditions and environment, the improvement of the quality and quantity of the food ration, a strategy to reduce prison overcrowding. Other actions must be planned to allow specific groups such as women and minors to have access to health care that is adapted to them. Beyond the central concern of promoting the rights of prisoners and humanizing prisons, actions to improve the health of prisoners are part of an overall public health approach with its socio-economic and environmental implications.
There is a need for a strong commitment from the State to develop a prison health policy that prioritizes the prevention of communicable and non-communicable diseases that are particularly prevalent in this context, without forgetting mental health and nutrition. This requires a collaboration of stakeholders based on better intersectorial communication, the implementation of a monitoring and evaluation system for the health of prisoners, an enhancement of the status of health-care providers working in prisons and an increase in the funding allocated to the health of prisoners with the mobilization of the necessary funds.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: This study uses a primary health care classification to assess the health of inmates in a prison in Africa. It contributes to the weak evidence around prison health surveillance and health profiling of prisoners in Africa.
本文旨在研究关押在两个最大的还押和惩教设施(RCF)中的囚犯中与疾病和脚气病发生相关的因素。
设计/方法/途径:这是一项横断面描述性和分析性研究,于2017年4月20日至5月19日在瓦加杜古和博博迪乌拉索的RCF中进行。所有前来咨询以及由医疗团队转介至健康中心的囚犯均纳入研究。使用国际初级保健分类第二版(ICPC - 2)收集投诉和诊断疾病信息。作者使用逻辑回归模型进行单变量和多变量分析。
纳入研究的来自两个RCF的1004名囚犯中(32.6%),966名(96%)为男性。中位年龄为31.6岁。使用ICPC - 2诊断的疾病分布显示,206名(19.3%)、188名(17.6%)和184名(17.2%)囚犯中分别以胃肠道、皮肤和呼吸道疾病为主。共有302名囚犯(30.1%)患有临床脚气病,80名囚犯(8%)体重过轻。被监禁超过九个月与消化和呼吸系统疾病以及脚气病的高风险独立相关。
研究局限性/影响:本研究突出了布基纳法索两个最大拘留中心中消化、皮肤和呼吸道投诉及疾病的较高发生率。这些疾病与年龄、刑罚状况和监禁时长存在不同程度的关联。此外,体重过轻和导致脚气病的硫胺素维生素缺乏在成年囚犯、未上学的囚犯、被定罪的囚犯以及拘留时长超过九个月的囚犯中更为常见。这些具体结果应有助于确定降低监狱发病率所需的策略和优先行动。
这些行动应包括监狱常见疾病领域专家的干预、个人卫生条件和环境的改善、食物配给质量和数量的提高、减少监狱过度拥挤的策略。还必须规划其他行动,以使妇女和未成年人等特定群体能够获得适合他们的医疗保健。除了促进囚犯权利和使监狱人性化这一核心关切之外,改善囚犯健康的行动是具有社会经济和环境影响的整体公共卫生方法的一部分。
国家需要坚定承诺制定一项监狱健康政策,优先预防在此背景下特别普遍的传染病和非传染病,同时不忘心理健康和营养。这需要利益相关者基于更好的部门间沟通进行协作,实施囚犯健康监测和评估系统,提高在监狱工作的医疗保健人员的地位,并通过筹集必要资金增加分配给囚犯健康的资金。
原创性/价值:本研究使用初级保健分类来评估非洲一所监狱中囚犯的健康状况。它为非洲监狱健康监测和囚犯健康概况方面薄弱的证据做出了贡献。