Fovet T, Lancelevée C, Eck M, Scouflaire T, Bécache E, Dandelot D, Giravalli P, Guillard A, Horrach P, Lacambre M, Lefebvre T, Moncany A-H, Touitou D, David M, Thomas P
CHU de Lille, Pôle de psychiatrie, 59000 Lille, France; Université Lille, Inserm, U1172 - Lille Neuroscience & Cognition - Équipe Plasticity & Subjectivity, 59000 Lille, France.
Fédération de recherches en psychiatrie et santé mentale des Hauts-de-France (F2RSM Psy), Saint-André-Lez-Lille, France.
Encephale. 2020 Jun;46(3S):S60-S65. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2020.05.002. Epub 2020 May 8.
The impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on the 11 million people currently incarcerated worldwide is the subject of many concerns. Prisons and jails are filled with people suffering from many preexisting medical conditions increasing the risk of complications. Detainees' access to medical services is already limited and overcrowding poses a threat of massive contagion. Beyond the health impact of the crisis, the tightening of prison conditions worries. On March 16, 2020, in France, the lockdown measures have been accompanied by specific provisions for prisons: all facilities have suspended visitations, group activities and external interventions. Over 10,000 prisoners have been released to reduce the prison population and the risk of virus propagation. These adjustments had major consequences on the healthcare system in French prisons. The objectives of this article are to describe the reorganization of the three levels of psychiatric care for inmates in France in the context of Covid-19 pandemic and to have a look at the impact of lockdown measures and early releases on mental health of prisoners.
This work is based on a survey conducted in April 2020 in France among psychiatric healthcare providers working in 42 ambulatory units for inmates and in the 9 full-time inpatient psychiatric wards exclusively for inmates called "UHSAs" (which stands for "unités hospitalières spécialement aménagées", and can be translated as "specially equipped hospital units"). A review of the international literature on mental healthcare system for inmates during the Covid-19 epidemic has also been performed.
The Covid-19 epidemic has been rather contained during the period of confinement in French prisons but the impact of confinement measures on the prison population is significant. The three levels of psychiatric care for inmates have implemented specific measures to ensure continuity of care, to support detainees during Coronavirus lockdown and to prevent an infection's spread. Among the most important are: limitation of medical consultations to serious and urgent cases, creation of "Covid units", cancellation of voluntary psychiatric hospitalizations, reinforcement of preventive hygiene measures and reshuffling of medical staff. Prolonged confinement has consequences on mental health of detainees. Currently, mental health workers are facing multiple clinical situations such as forced drug and substance withdrawal (linked to difficulties in supplying psychoactive substances), symptoms of anxiety (due to concerns for their own and their relatives' well-being) and decompensation among patients with severe psychiatric conditions. Early releases from prison may also raise some issues. People recently released from prison are identified as at high risk of death by suicide and drug overdose. The lack of time to provide the necessary link between health services within prisons and health structures outside could have serious consequences, emphasizing the well-known "revolving prison doors" effect.
The current lockdown measures applied in French jails and prisons point out the disparities between psychiatric care for inmates and psychiatric care for general population. Giving the high vulnerability of prison population, public health authorities should pay more attention to health care in prisons.
新冠疫情对全球1100万在押人员的影响引发了诸多关注。监狱中关押着许多患有多种基础疾病的人员,这增加了并发症的风险。被拘留者获得医疗服务的机会本就有限,而过度拥挤又构成了大规模传染的威胁。除了危机对健康的影响,监狱条件的收紧也令人担忧。2020年3月16日,法国在实施封锁措施的同时,还针对监狱出台了具体规定:所有设施暂停探视、集体活动和外部干预。超过10000名囚犯被释放,以减少监狱人口和病毒传播风险。这些调整对法国监狱的医疗系统产生了重大影响。本文的目的是描述在新冠疫情背景下法国监狱中针对囚犯的三级精神科护理的重组情况,并探讨封锁措施和提前释放对囚犯心理健康的影响。
这项工作基于2020年4月在法国对42个囚犯门诊单位以及9个专门为囚犯设立的全职住院精神科病房(称为“UHSAs”,即“特别配备的医院单位”)的精神科医疗服务提供者进行的一项调查。还对新冠疫情期间关于囚犯精神卫生保健系统的国际文献进行了综述。
在法国监狱的禁闭期间,新冠疫情得到了一定程度的控制,但禁闭措施对监狱人口的影响很大。针对囚犯的三级精神科护理采取了具体措施,以确保护理的连续性,在新冠病毒封锁期间支持被拘留者,并防止感染传播。其中最重要的措施包括:将医疗咨询限制在严重和紧急病例,设立“新冠病房”,取消自愿住院精神病治疗,加强预防性卫生措施以及调整医护人员。长期禁闭对被拘留者的心理健康产生了影响。目前,精神卫生工作者面临多种临床情况,如强制戒毒和戒断(与供应精神活性物质困难有关)、焦虑症状(由于对自身和亲属健康的担忧)以及重症精神病患者的病情恶化。提前释放囚犯也可能引发一些问题。最近从监狱释放的人员被确定为有自杀和药物过量死亡的高风险。监狱内卫生服务与外部卫生机构之间缺乏时间建立必要的联系可能会产生严重后果,这凸显了众所周知的“监狱旋转门”效应。
法国监狱目前实施的封锁措施指出了囚犯精神科护理与普通人群精神科护理之间的差异。鉴于监狱人口的高度脆弱性,公共卫生当局应更加关注监狱中的医疗保健。