National Biosafety Laboratory, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Wuhan 430020, China.
Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Wuhan 430020, China.
Viruses. 2021 Aug 10;13(8):1575. doi: 10.3390/v13081575.
Given that ebolavirus causes severe and frequently lethal disease, its rapid and accurate detection using available and validated methods is essential for controlling infection. Real-time reverse-transcription PCR (RT-PCR) has proven to be an invaluable tool for ebolaviruses diagnostics. Many assays with different targets have been developed, but they have not been externally compared or validated, and limits of detection are not uniformly reported. Here we compared and evaluated the sensitivity, reproducibility and specificity of 23 in-house assays under the same conditions. Our results showed that these assays were highly gene- and species- specific when evaluated using in vitro RNA transcripts and viral RNA, and the potential limits of detection were uniformly reported ranging from 10 to 10 in vitro synthesized RNA transcripts copies perμL and 1-100 TCID/mL. The comparison of these assays indicated that those targeting the more conservative NP gene could be the better option for EVD case definition and quantitative measurement because of its higher sensitivity for the same species. Our analysis could contribute to the standardization of ebolavirus detection and quantification assays, which can offer a better understanding of the meaning of results across laboratories and time points, as well as make them easy to implement, especially under outbreak conditions.
鉴于埃博拉病毒会引起严重且常常致命的疾病,因此使用现有且经过验证的方法快速且准确地检测埃博拉病毒对于控制感染至关重要。实时逆转录聚合酶链反应(RT-PCR)已被证明是埃博拉病毒诊断的一种非常有价值的工具。已经开发出许多具有不同靶标的检测方法,但它们尚未进行外部比较或验证,并且检测限也没有统一报告。在这里,我们在相同条件下比较和评估了 23 种内部检测方法的灵敏度、重现性和特异性。我们的结果表明,当使用体外 RNA 转录本和病毒 RNA 评估时,这些检测方法具有高度的基因和物种特异性,并且均匀报告了潜在的检测限,范围从 10 到 10 个体外合成的 RNA 转录本拷贝/μL 和 1-100 组织培养感染剂量/mL。对这些检测方法的比较表明,针对更保守的 NP 基因的检测方法可能是 EVD 病例定义和定量测量的更好选择,因为其对同一物种的灵敏度更高。我们的分析有助于埃博拉病毒检测和定量检测方法的标准化,这可以更好地理解不同实验室和时间点的结果的含义,并且使它们易于实施,特别是在暴发情况下。