Department of Veterinary Population Medicine, University of Minnesota, St. Paul 55108.
ACER Consulting, Guelph, Ontario, Canada, N1G 5L3.
J Dairy Sci. 2021 Nov;104(11):11889-11903. doi: 10.3168/jds.2021-20603. Epub 2021 Aug 26.
Lameness is a leading animal welfare concern in the dairy industry. Multiple stakeholders are involved in lameness management on a dairy farm, including farmers, hoof trimmers, and veterinarians. This study sought to explore perceptions of lameness, perceptions of roles in lameness management, and barriers to improved lameness management in these groups. Fourteen homogeneous focus groups were held in Minnesota, Wisconsin, and New York from April 2017 to March 2020; 5 with farmers (n = 31), 4 with hoof trimmers (n = 32), and 5 with veterinarians (n = 25). The 1-h facilitated discussions were audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim, and common themes identified through thematic analysis. Lameness was perceived by participants as a complex health problem and one in which the connections between pathogenesis, facilities, and management were not always well understood or easy to change. The complexity of the problem encompassed the lack of agreement on a definition of lameness, normalization to its signs, and the interconnectedness of lameness with other health and management issues. These issues appeared to contribute to resignation by participants that lameness was inevitable. Despite shared concerns about lameness among these groups, respondents reported a lack of communication, especially between hoof trimmers and veterinarians. Participants also voiced a desire to work together more productively, with hoof trimmers and veterinarians valuing the ability to deliver a consistent message to farmers. These findings suggest a need for increased efforts to facilitate collaboration between farmers, hoof trimmers, and veterinarians to improve lameness management on dairy farms.
跛行是奶牛养殖业中主要的动物福利问题。在奶牛场的跛行管理中,多个利益相关者都参与其中,包括农民、蹄修师和兽医。本研究旨在探讨这些群体对跛行的看法、对跛行管理角色的看法以及改善跛行管理的障碍。2017 年 4 月至 2020 年 3 月,在明尼苏达州、威斯康星州和纽约州进行了 14 次同质焦点小组讨论;其中 5 次与农民(n = 31)、4 次与蹄修师(n = 32)、5 次与兽医(n = 25)进行了讨论。这些 1 小时的讨论由主持人引导,进行了录音、逐字记录,并通过主题分析确定了共同主题。参与者认为跛行是一个复杂的健康问题,在这个问题中,发病机制、设施和管理之间的联系并不总是被很好地理解或易于改变。问题的复杂性包括对跛行定义缺乏共识、对其迹象的正常化以及跛行与其他健康和管理问题的相互关联性。这些问题似乎导致参与者们对跛行不可避免感到无奈。尽管这些群体对跛行有共同的关注,但受访者报告说缺乏沟通,特别是蹄修师和兽医之间的沟通。参与者还表示希望更有效地合作,蹄修师和兽医都希望能够向农民传达一致的信息。这些发现表明,需要加大努力,促进农民、蹄修师和兽医之间的合作,以改善奶牛场的跛行管理。