Ratan Bani M, Greely Jocelyn T, Jensen M Diane, Kilpatrick Charlie C
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX USA.
Med Sci Educ. 2020 May 27;30(3):1169-1176. doi: 10.1007/s40670-020-00985-2. eCollection 2020 Sep.
The learning environment in obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYN) may have intrinsic differences that require modifying existing resident as teacher models for high-quality teaching.
To explore medical students' views of resident teaching on the OB/GYN clerkship in order to develop more effective educators.
Between October 2017 and June 2018, we performed medical student focus groups at the end of the 2-month OB/GYN clerkship. Topics discussed included positive and negative teaching interactions with residents, barriers specific to the OB/GYN clerkship, and best methods for resident teaching. Qualitative analysis utilizing 3 reviewers and N-Vivo software were used to identify themes.
A total of 37 students participated in five focus groups. The most common barriers were a learning environment that was less predictable than on other rotations and lack of autonomy due to patient advocacy concerns. The three main contributors to positive learning experiences were team inclusion, clear expectations, and feedback. Negative interactions were passive learning experiences and inconsistent expectations. The best methods for resident teaching were verbalization of cognitive processes, preparation to use common patient encounters as teaching moments, and modeling skills needed for proficient patient care.
The learning environment on OB/GYN is unpredictable and influenced by four Ps: patient autonomy, passive experiences, procedures, and preconceived notions. The strategy of a resident teacher should focus on medical student inclusion and preparation for teaching role. We thus suggest a TEAM (hinking Aloud, xpectations, dvanced Preparation, odeling) approach to improve resident teaching on the OB/GYN clerkship.
妇产科的学习环境可能存在内在差异,这需要对现有的住院医师带教模式进行调整以实现高质量教学。
探讨医学生对妇产科实习中住院医师教学的看法,以便培养更有效的教育者。
在2017年10月至2018年6月期间,我们在为期2个月的妇产科实习结束时组织了医学生焦点小组讨论。讨论的主题包括与住院医师的积极和消极教学互动、妇产科实习特有的障碍以及住院医师教学的最佳方法。利用3名评审员和N-Vivo软件进行定性分析以确定主题。
共有37名学生参加了5个焦点小组。最常见的障碍是学习环境比其他轮转更不可预测,以及由于患者权益问题而缺乏自主性。积极学习体验的三个主要因素是团队融入、明确期望和反馈。消极互动是被动学习体验和期望不一致。住院医师教学的最佳方法是阐述认知过程、准备将常见的患者诊疗过程作为教学时机以及示范熟练的患者护理所需技能。
妇产科的学习环境不可预测,受四个“P”影响:患者自主性、被动体验、诊疗操作和先入之见。住院医师教师的策略应侧重于医学生的融入和教学角色的准备。因此,我们建议采用TEAM(大声思考、期望、提前准备、示范)方法来改善妇产科实习中的住院医师教学。