Shashikumar Ramadugu, Agarwal Kruti, Mohammad Aiman, Kaushik Chatterjee
Department of Psychiatry, Mahavir Institute of Medical Sciences, Vikarabad, Telangana, India.
Department of Psychiatry, Armed Forces Medical College, Pune, Maharashtra, India.
Ind Psychiatry J. 2021 Jan-Jun;30(1):147-152. doi: 10.4103/ipj.ipj_63_21. Epub 2021 Jun 30.
Empathy a cognitive phenomenon, with affective and behavioral components; helps improve clinical competence. It varies depending on physicians' gender and specialty. While some western studies reported significant fall in empathy levels when they progressed from non-clinical to clinical training years, Asian studies including Indian had varied results. We hypothesize that empathy will decrease among medical undergraduates over four years while they progress from non- clinical to clinical rotations and that female medical students and those opting for clinical specialties will have higher empathy than male medical students and those opting for non clinical specialty.
This study was carried out in a medical college from the year 2012 to 2015. Each year at the beginning of academic session all students were asked to complete Jefferson's -Scale for Physician's Empathy (JSPE student) student version. Over next three years similar assessments were repeated for all batches. The results were tabulated and analyzed using EpiInfo7 software.
Over four years 481, 416, 412 and 354 medical students in 1, 2, 3 and 4 year respectively from seven different batches were evaluated. Choice of specialty differed significantly in each year different batches. The empathy score had no relation to gender or choice of specialty. Empathy declines from first year onwards till third year but is not statistically significant.
In this large multiple sample cross sectional study, it is evident empathy drops from 1 to 3 year therefore there is an urgent need to evaluate why empathy falls.
同理心是一种认知现象,包含情感和行为成分;有助于提高临床能力。它因医生的性别和专业不同而有所差异。虽然一些西方研究报告称,从非临床培训阶段进入临床培训阶段后,同理心水平会显著下降,但包括印度在内的亚洲研究结果各不相同。我们假设,医学本科生在从非临床实习过渡到临床实习的四年间,同理心会下降,而且女医学生以及选择临床专业的学生比男医学生和选择非临床专业的学生具有更高的同理心。
本研究于2012年至2015年在一所医学院进行。每年在学术课程开始时,要求所有学生完成杰斐逊医生同理心量表(JSPE学生版)。在接下来的三年里,对所有批次的学生重复进行类似评估。使用EpiInfo7软件将结果制成表格并进行分析。
在四年时间里,分别对来自七个不同批次的一年级、二年级、三年级和四年级的481名、416名、412名和354名医学生进行了评估。每年不同批次学生的专业选择差异显著。同理心得分与性别或专业选择无关。同理心从第一年到第三年呈下降趋势,但无统计学意义。
在这项大型多样本横断面研究中,很明显同理心从第一年到第三年呈下降趋势,因此迫切需要评估同理心下降的原因。