Department of Orthopedics, Shanghai Xuhui Hospital, Shanghai, China.
Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci. 2021 Aug;25(16):5189-5198. doi: 10.26355/eurrev_202108_26532.
The present study aimed to investigate the impact of two Nrf2 agonists, tBHQ and 4-Octyl Itaconate, on nucleus pulposus (NP) degeneration and explore the underlying mechanism.
We isolated the NP cells from the disc tissue of disc herniation patients. NP cells were pretreated with an adequate dose of tBHQ, Itaconate, or the mixture of them, and then subjected to the Lipopolysaccharides (LPS) stimulation to induce degeneration. Besides, the Nrf2 gene silenced NP cells were also used as a comparison. Moreover, the LPS-treated NP cells were also cultured in the mix of tBHQ and Itaconate to determine whether the agonists affected reverse degeneration.
LPS treatment suppressed Nrf2 expression and induced the NP cell degeneration with a decrease of cell viability and collagen II expression, an increase of reactive oxygen species (ROS) production, inflammatory cytokine accumulation (IL-1β, TNF-α), and apoptosis (Caspase3, Caspase8). However, tBHQ or Itaconate pretreated NP cells contained a higher level of Nrf2 protein and alleviated the negative effect caused by LPS, which was abolished with the silencing of Nrf2. Additionally, tBHQ showed a better ability to suppress ROS than Itaconate. Meanwhile, Itaconate inhibited a higher amount of IL-1β and TNF-α than tBHQ. Interestingly, when NP cells were pretreated with both tBHQ and Itaconate, the result indicated an excellent anti-ROS and anti-inflammatory peculiarity. Furthermore, when NP cells suffered from LPS first and then treated with the agonist, the anti-ROS and anti-inflammatory effects remained. However, the cell viability, collagen II, and apoptotic degree were not improved.
Both tBHQ and Itaconate effectively prevent NP cells from degeneration through anti-ROS and anti-inflammation, and the combined use of them may have better effects. But in comparison, their impact on reversing NP cell degeneration has yet to be proven.
本研究旨在探讨两种 Nrf2 激动剂 TBHQ 和 4-辛基衣康酸对髓核(NP)退变的影响,并探讨其潜在机制。
我们从椎间盘突出症患者的椎间盘组织中分离出 NP 细胞。用适当剂量的 TBHQ、衣康酸或它们的混合物预处理 NP 细胞,然后用脂多糖(LPS)刺激诱导退变。此外,还使用沉默 Nrf2 基因的 NP 细胞作为对照。另外,将 LPS 处理的 NP 细胞也培养在 TBHQ 和衣康酸的混合物中,以确定激动剂是否影响逆转退变。
LPS 处理抑制了 Nrf2 的表达,并诱导 NP 细胞退变,表现为细胞活力和胶原 II 表达降低,活性氧(ROS)产生增加,炎症细胞因子(IL-1β、TNF-α)积累和凋亡(Caspase3、Caspase8)增加。然而,TBHQ 或衣康酸预处理的 NP 细胞含有更高水平的 Nrf2 蛋白,并减轻了 LPS 引起的负性作用,而 Nrf2 的沉默则消除了这种作用。此外,TBHQ 抑制 ROS 的能力优于衣康酸。同时,衣康酸抑制的 IL-1β 和 TNF-α 量高于 TBHQ。有趣的是,当 NP 细胞先用 TBHQ 和衣康酸预处理后再用激动剂处理时,结果显示出优异的抗 ROS 和抗炎特性。此外,当 NP 细胞先受到 LPS 处理,然后再用激动剂处理时,抗 ROS 和抗炎作用仍然存在。然而,细胞活力、胶原 II 和凋亡程度没有改善。
TBHQ 和衣康酸通过抗 ROS 和抗炎有效防止 NP 细胞退变,两者联合使用可能效果更好。但相比之下,它们对逆转 NP 细胞退变的影响尚未得到证实。