Ross Anna M, Morgan Amy J, Wake Alexandra, Jorm Anthony F, Reavley Nicola J
Melbourne School of Global and Population Health, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
School of Media and Communication, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia.
Health Promot J Austr. 2022 Jul;33(3):602-613. doi: 10.1002/hpja.537. Epub 2021 Sep 15.
News reports linking mental illness to violent crime are among the most stigmatising portrayals. These portrayals can perpetuate stereotypes of dangerousness, negatively influencing public attitudes and having a harmful impact on people with lived experience of mental illness. With the aim of improving the quality of news portrayals and mitigating harm, best-practice guidelines for media reporting on mental illness, violence and crime have been developed. To increase understanding of the guidelines' content, a 1-hour workshop based on the main principles was developed for journalism students.
In this study, the workshop was piloted with a pre and 3-week follow-up evaluation with a cohort of journalism students (n = 29).
Three weeks after the workshop, there were significant improvements in attitudes towards severe mental illness, knowledge of best-practice reporting, intentions and confidence to report consistently with the best-practice guidelines and performance on an editing task designed to assess adherence to the guidelines. Belief in dangerousness/unpredictability reduced markedly, demonstrating that the workshop effectively addressed misinformation about people with severe mental illness being a risk to the public.
This pilot trial provides promising initial results and provides a basis for wider implementation and evaluation of media training on this topic.
Improved understanding of best-practice media guidelines, as generated through this workshop, has potential to reduce stigmatising news reporting on people with mental illness, and consequently reduce public stigma.
将精神疾病与暴力犯罪联系起来的新闻报道是最具污名化的描述之一。这些描述会使危险的刻板印象长期存在,对公众态度产生负面影响,并对有精神疾病亲身经历的人造成伤害。为了提高新闻报道的质量并减轻危害,已制定了关于精神疾病、暴力和犯罪的媒体报道最佳实践指南。为了增进对指南内容的理解,为新闻专业学生举办了一场基于主要原则的1小时工作坊。
在本研究中,对一组新闻专业学生(n = 29)进行了工作坊试点,并进行了前期和为期3周的随访评估。
工作坊三周后,对严重精神疾病的态度、最佳实践报道的知识、按照最佳实践指南进行报道的意图和信心以及在旨在评估对指南遵守情况的编辑任务中的表现都有显著改善。对危险性/不可预测性的信念明显降低,表明该工作坊有效地解决了关于严重精神疾病患者对公众构成风险的错误信息。
这项试点试验提供了有希望的初步结果,并为在该主题上更广泛地开展媒体培训及评估提供了基础。
通过该工作坊提高对最佳实践媒体指南的理解,有可能减少对患有精神疾病者的污名化新闻报道,从而减少公众的污名化。