Department of Radiology, Skaraborg Hospital, Skövde, Sweden.
Department of Radiation Physics, Institute of Clinical Sciences, Sahlgrenska Academy at University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden.
J Appl Clin Med Phys. 2021 Oct;22(10):295-304. doi: 10.1002/acm2.13421. Epub 2021 Sep 10.
The aim of the present study was to demonstrate cases of cost-benefit analysis within healthcare, of how economic factors can be considered in occupational radiological protection, in agreement with the as low as reasonably achievable principle and present Swedish legislations. In the first part of the present study, a comparison of examples within health economics used by authorities and institutes in Sweden was made. The comparison focused on value of a statistical life, quality-adjusted life year, and monetary cost assigned to a unit of collective dose for radiation protection purposes (α-value). By this comparison, an α-value was determined as an interval between $45 and $450 per man-mSv, for the Swedish society in 2021. The α-value interval can be interpreted as following: Less than $45 per man-mSv is a good investment. From $45 to $450 per man-mSv, other factors than costs and collective dose are important to consider. More than $450 per man-mSv is too expensive. In the second part of the present study, seven cases of cost-benefit analyses in occupational radiological protection were provided. The present study focused specifically on cases where the relevant factors were costs and collective dose. The present case study shows a large variation in costs per collective dose from different types of occupational radiological protection, used at Skaraborg Hospital in Sweden.
本研究旨在展示医疗保健领域内的成本效益分析案例,说明如何根据尽可能合理低原则和瑞典现行法规,将经济因素纳入职业放射防护工作中。本研究的第一部分对瑞典各主管部门和机构在卫生经济学中使用的实例进行了比较。比较的重点是统计生命价值、质量调整生命年以及为辐射防护目的而分配给集体剂量单位的货币成本(α 值)。通过这种比较,确定了 2021 年瑞典社会的 α 值区间在 45 美元至 450 美元/人·mSv 之间。该 α 值区间可以解读为:低于 45 美元/人·mSv 为划算投资;45 美元至 450 美元/人·mSv 之间,除成本和集体剂量外,其他因素也很重要;超过 450 美元/人·mSv 则过于昂贵。本研究的第二部分提供了七个职业放射防护的成本效益分析案例。本研究特别关注的是相关因素为成本和集体剂量的案例。本案例研究表明,瑞典斯科讷省斯科纳大学医院使用的不同类型职业放射防护的集体剂量成本存在很大差异。