Department of Urology, Singapore General Hospital, Singapore, Singapore.
Department of Urology, Marmara University School of Medicine, Istanbul, Turkey.
J Endourol. 2022 Feb;36(2):279-286. doi: 10.1089/end.2021.0445.
With webinars looking to be the mainstay post-pandemic, it is important to demonstrate whether webinars are, indeed, effective educational tools for professional training and skill acquisition. We aim at demonstrating, via a global survey, the efficacy of webinars on percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) and how this knowledge transforms clinical practice. A structured online survey covering the following sections: (1) Demographics, (2) PCNL techniques, and (3) PCNL equipment was circulated. The target study population were practicing urologists and residents. Categorical data were presented with counts and percentages, and they were compared by using Chi-square test. Continuous data were analyzed with non-parametric methods. Respondents were dichotomized according to attendance of webinar type, attendees of dedicated PCNL webinars (Group A), or attendees of endourological webinars that discussed some aspects of PCNL (Group B). A total of 303 respondents from 38 countries participated. Overall, 91.7% ( = 278) were in Group A and 8.3% ( = 25) were in Group B; 77.9% were younger than 50 years, whereas 51.8% had more than 10 years of urology experience. In group A, urologists of all ages, in academic institutions and private practitioners, significantly benefited in gaining knowledge about the merits of newer devices and the role of suction-assisted devices in modern PCNL. The majority of group A also reflected that by attending a dedicated PCNL-based webinar they benefited in learning newer positions for PCNL access, especially supine, and how to effectively use laser as energy devices for lithotripsy. In Group B, the only area of benefit was in lasing techniques and the use of newer lasers such as the thulium fibre laser. Our survey positively validates the two proposed hypothesis, that is, webinars as a medium of education do benefit practicing urologists in knowledge and the clinical practice domains. Age, experience, or place of practice is no barrier to adopting newer mediums of education such as webinars.
随着网络研讨会在后疫情时代成为主要形式,证明网络研讨会是否确实是专业培训和技能获取的有效教育工具变得尤为重要。我们旨在通过全球调查证明网络研讨会在经皮肾镜取石术(PCNL)中的有效性,以及这种知识如何转化为临床实践。 一项涵盖以下部分的结构化在线调查:(1)人口统计学,(2)PCNL 技术,和(3)PCNL 设备。目标研究人群是执业泌尿科医生和住院医师。分类数据以计数和百分比表示,并通过卡方检验进行比较。连续数据采用非参数方法进行分析。根据网络研讨会类型的出席情况将受访者分为两组,专门的 PCNL 网络研讨会(A 组)或讨论 PCNL 某些方面的内镜手术网络研讨会(B 组)的参与者。 来自 38 个国家的 303 名受访者参与了这项研究。总体而言,91.7%(278 名)在 A 组,8.3%(25 名)在 B 组;77.9%的人年龄在 50 岁以下,而 51.8%的人有超过 10 年的泌尿科经验。在 A 组中,所有年龄段的泌尿科医生,无论是在学术机构还是私人诊所工作,都显著受益于了解新型设备的优点以及抽吸辅助设备在现代 PCNL 中的作用。大多数 A 组的人还反映,通过参加专门的基于 PCNL 的网络研讨会,他们受益于学习 PCNL 入路的新体位,特别是仰卧位,以及如何有效地将激光用作碎石的能量设备。在 B 组中,唯一受益的领域是激光技术和使用新型激光,如铥光纤激光。 我们的调查肯定验证了两个提出的假设,即网络研讨会作为一种教育媒介确实使执业泌尿科医生在知识和临床实践领域受益。年龄、经验或执业地点都不会成为采用网络研讨会等新型教育媒介的障碍。