Mullins Ronan A, Escribano Carrera Antía, Anderson Davina M, Billet Jean-Philippe, Brissot Herve, Broome Cameron, de Rooster Hilde, Kirby Barbara M, Pratschke Kathryn M, Tivers Michael S, White Robert N, Yool Donald A, Youmans K Ruth
Section of Small Animal Clinical Sciences, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Anderson Moores Veterinary Specialists, Winchester, UK.
Vet Surg. 2022 Jan;51(1):23-33. doi: 10.1111/vsu.13729. Epub 2021 Sep 29.
The development of postattenuation neurologic signs (PANS) is a poorly understood and potentially devastating complication after surgical attenuation of congenital portosystemic shunts in dogs. Postattenuation neurologic signs include seizures but also more subtle neurologic signs such as depression, behavioral changes, tremors, and twitching. They most commonly occur within 7 days postoperatively and are typically unrelated to hyperammonemia, hypoglycemia, or electrolyte disturbances. This narrative review summarizes the findings of 50 publications from 1988-2020 that report occurrence of PANS. While most published reports included only dogs affected by postattenuation seizures (PAS), others included dogs with any form of PANS. Overall, PANS (including PAS) affected 1.6%-27.3% of dogs, whereas incidence of PAS ranged from 0%-18.2%. The etiology of PANS remains unknown; however, several theories have been proposed. Risk factors include preoperative hepatic encephalopathy, increasing age, and possibly certain breeds and extrahepatic shunt morphology. There is increasing evidence that prophylactic antiepileptic drugs do not prevent PANS. Treatment is centered around controlling neurologic signs with antiepileptic drugs and providing supportive intensive care. The 30-day survival rate in studies that included a minimum of four dogs affected by PANS was 0%-100% (median, 50.0%) and 0%-75.0% (median, 37.5%) for those with PAS. Mortality associated with PANS was typically related to occurrence of generalized seizure activity. Prognostic factors positively associated with short-term survival included having a history of preoperative seizures and development of focal seizures only. If affected dogs survived to discharge, survival for several years was possible, and the majority of neurologic signs manifested as part of the phenomenon of PANS appeared to resolve.
先天性门体分流手术减流术后出现的减流后神经症状(PANS)是一种了解甚少且可能具有毁灭性的并发症。减流后神经症状包括癫痫发作,但也有更细微的神经症状,如抑郁、行为改变、震颤和抽搐。它们最常发生在术后7天内,通常与高氨血症、低血糖或电解质紊乱无关。这篇叙述性综述总结了1988年至2020年50篇报告PANS发生情况的出版物的研究结果。虽然大多数已发表的报告仅包括受减流后癫痫发作(PAS)影响的犬只,但其他报告也包括患有任何形式PANS的犬只。总体而言,PANS(包括PAS)影响了1.6%至27.3%的犬只,而PAS的发生率在0%至18.2%之间。PANS的病因仍然未知;然而,已经提出了几种理论。风险因素包括术前肝性脑病、年龄增长,可能还有某些品种和肝外分流形态。越来越多的证据表明预防性抗癫痫药物不能预防PANS。治疗以用抗癫痫药物控制神经症状并提供支持性重症监护为中心。在至少包括四只受PANS影响的犬只的研究中,30天生存率为0%至100%(中位数为50.0%),而患有PAS的犬只的30天生存率为0%至75.0%(中位数为37.5%)。与PANS相关的死亡率通常与全身性癫痫发作活动的发生有关。与短期生存呈正相关的预后因素包括有术前癫痫发作史且仅出现局灶性癫痫发作。如果受影响的犬只存活至出院,则有可能存活数年,并且大多数表现为PANS现象一部分的神经症状似乎会消失。