Sachs Jonathan W, Graven Peter, Gold Jeffrey A, Kassakian Steven Z
Department of Medical Informatics and Clinical Epidemiology, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, Oregon, USA.
JAMIA Open. 2021 Aug 2;4(3):ooab056. doi: 10.1093/jamiaopen/ooab056. eCollection 2021 Jul.
The COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent expansion of telehealth may be exacerbating inequities in ambulatory care access due to institutional and structural barriers. We conduct a repeat cross-sectional analysis of ambulatory patients to evaluate for demographic disparities in the utilization of telehealth modalities.
The ambulatory patient population at Oregon Health & Science University (Portland, OR, USA) is examined from June 1 through September 30, in 2019 (reference period) and in 2020 (study period). We first assess for changes in demographic representation and then evaluate for disparities in the utilization of telephone and video care modalities using logistic regression.
Between the 2019 and 2020 periods, patient video utilization increased from 0.2% to 31%, and telephone use increased from 2.5% to 25%. There was also a small but significant decline in the representation males, Asians, Medicaid, Medicare, and non-English speaking patients. Amongst telehealth users, adjusted odds of video participation were significantly lower for those who were Black, American Indian, male, prefer a non-English language, have Medicaid or Medicare, or older.
A large portion of ambulatory patients shifted to telehealth modalities during the pandemic. Seniors, non-English speakers, and Black patients were more reliant on telephone than video for care. The differences in telehealth adoption by vulnerable populations demonstrate the tendency toward disparities that can occur in the expansion of telehealth and suggest structural biases.
Organizations should actively monitor the utilization of telehealth modalities and develop best-practice guidelines in order to mitigate the exacerbation of inequities.
由于制度和结构障碍,新冠疫情及随后远程医疗的扩展可能会加剧门诊医疗服务获取方面的不平等。我们对门诊患者进行重复横断面分析,以评估远程医疗模式使用中的人口统计学差异。
对美国俄勒冈健康与科学大学(俄勒冈州波特兰)2019年(参考期)和2020年(研究期)6月1日至9月30日的门诊患者群体进行研究。我们首先评估人口统计学代表性的变化,然后使用逻辑回归评估电话和视频护理模式使用中的差异。
在2019年至2020年期间,患者视频使用率从0.2%增至31%,电话使用率从2.5%增至25%。男性、亚洲人、医疗补助、医疗保险和非英语患者的占比也出现了小幅但显著的下降。在远程医疗用户中,黑人、美洲印第安人、男性、偏好非英语、有医疗补助或医疗保险或年龄较大的用户参与视频的调整后几率显著较低。
在疫情期间,很大一部分门诊患者转向了远程医疗模式。老年人、非英语使用者和黑人患者在就医时更依赖电话而非视频。弱势群体在采用远程医疗方面的差异表明,远程医疗扩展过程中可能会出现不平等倾向,并暗示存在结构偏见。
各机构应积极监测远程医疗模式的使用情况,并制定最佳实践指南,以减轻不平等加剧的情况。