Hey Hwee Weng Dennis, Lam Wing Moon Raymond, Chan Chloe Xiaoyun, Zhuo Wen-Hai, Crombie Elisa Marie, Tan Tuan Chun, Chen Way Cherng, Cool Simon, Tsai Shih Yin
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, National University Hospital, 1E Kent Ridge Road, NUHS Tower Block Level 11, Singapore 119228.
National University of Singapore Engineering Programme (NUSTEP), Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore (NUS), 10 Medical Dr, Singapore 117597.
Spine J. 2022 Mar;22(3):483-494. doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2021.09.003. Epub 2021 Oct 13.
Increasing kyphosis of the spine in a human is a well-recognized clinical phenomenon that has been associated with back pain, poor physical performance and disability. The pathophysiology of age-related kyphosis is complex and has been associated with physiological changes in vertebrae, intervertebral disc (IVD) and paraspinal musculature, which current cross-sectional studies are unable to demonstrate. Creating an in vivo, paraspinal myopathic animal model for longitudinal study of these changes under controlled conditions is thus warranted.
To confirm the TSC1 gene knockout effect on paraspinal muscle musculature; to analyze the development of spinal kyphosis, IVD degeneration and vertebra structural changes in a longitudinal manner to gain insights into the relationship between these processes.
A prospective cohort study of 28 female mice, divided into 4 groups-9-month-old TSC1mKO (n=7), 9-month-old control (n=4), 12-month-old TSC1mKO (n=8), and 12-month-old controls (n=9).
High resolution micro-computed tomography was used to measure sagittal spinal alignment (Cobb's angle), vertebral height, vertebral body wedging, disc height index (DHI), disc wedge index (DWI), histomorphometry of trabecular bone and erector spinae muscle cross-sectional area. Paraspinal muscle specimens were harvested to assess for myopathic features with H&E stain, muscle fiber size, density of triangular fiber and central nucleus with WGA/DAPI stain, and percentage of fibers with PGC-1α stain. Intervertebral discs were evaluated for disc score using FAST stain.
Compared to controls, paraspinal muscle sections revealed features of myopathy in TSC1mKO mice similar to human sarcopenic paraspinal muscle. While there was significantly greater presence of small triangular fiber and density of central nucleus in 9-and 12-month-old TSC1mKO mice, significantly larger muscle fibers and decreased erector spinae muscle cross-sectional area were only found in 12-month-old TSC1mKO mice compared to controls. TSC1mKO mice developed accelerated thoracolumbar kyphosis, with significantly larger Cobb angles found only at 12 months old. Structural changes to the trabecular bone in terms of higher bone volume fraction and quality, as well as vertebral body wedging were observed only in 12-month-old TSC1mKO mice when compared to controls. Disc degeneration was observed as early as 9 months in TSC1mKO mice and corresponded with disc wedging. However, significant disc height loss was only observed when comparing 12-month-old TSC1mKO mice with controls.
This study successfully shows the TSC1 gene knockout effect on the development of paraspinal muscle myopathy in a mouse which is characteristic of sarcopenia. The TSC1mKO mice is by far the best model available to study the pathological consequence of sarcopenia on mice spine. With paraspinal muscle myopathy established as early as 9 months, TSC1mKO mice developed disc degeneration and disc wedging. This is followed by kyphosis of the spine at 12 months with concomitant disc height loss and vertebral body wedging due to bone remodeling. Age-related bone loss was not found in our study, suggesting osteoporosis and myopathy-induced vertebral body wedging are likely two independent processes.
This is the first study to provide key insights on the early and late consequences of paraspinal myopathy on intervertebral disc degeneration, spinal kyphosis, and vertebral body changes. With this new understanding, future studies evaluating therapies for spinal degeneration may be performed to develop time-sensitive interventions.
人类脊柱后凸增加是一种公认的临床现象,与背痛、身体机能差和残疾有关。年龄相关性脊柱后凸的病理生理学很复杂,与椎体、椎间盘(IVD)和椎旁肌肉组织的生理变化有关,而目前的横断面研究无法证实这些变化。因此,有必要建立一种体内椎旁肌病动物模型,以便在可控条件下对这些变化进行纵向研究。
确认TSC1基因敲除对椎旁肌肉组织的影响;纵向分析脊柱后凸、IVD退变和椎体结构变化的发展情况,以深入了解这些过程之间的关系。
对28只雌性小鼠进行前瞻性队列研究,分为4组——9个月大的TSC1基因敲除小鼠(n = 7)、9个月大的对照组(n = )、12个月大的TSC1基因敲除小鼠(n = 8)和12个月大的对照组(n = 9)。
使用高分辨率微型计算机断层扫描测量脊柱矢状位排列(Cobb角)、椎体高度、椎体楔形变、椎间盘高度指数(DHI)、椎间盘楔变指数(DWI)、小梁骨组织形态计量学和竖脊肌横截面积。采集椎旁肌肉标本,用苏木精和伊红染色评估肌病特征,用WGA/DAPI染色评估肌纤维大小、三角形纤维密度和中央核,用PGC-1α染色评估纤维百分比。使用FAST染色评估椎间盘退变程度。
与对照组相比,TSC1基因敲除小鼠的椎旁肌肉切片显示出与人类少肌性椎旁肌相似的肌病特征。虽然在9个月和12个月大的TSC1基因敲除小鼠中,小三角形纤维的存在和中央核的密度显著增加,但与对照组相比,仅在12个月大的TSC1基因敲除小鼠中发现肌纤维明显更大且竖脊肌横截面积减小。TSC1基因敲除小鼠出现胸腰椎后凸加速,仅在12个月大时Cobb角显著增大。与对照组相比,仅在12个月大的TSC1基因敲除小鼠中观察到小梁骨在骨体积分数和质量方面的结构变化以及椎体楔形变。TSC1基因敲除小鼠早在9个月时就观察到椎间盘退变,且与椎间盘楔变相关。然而,仅在将12个月大的TSC1基因敲除小鼠与对照组比较时才观察到椎间盘高度显著降低。
本研究成功显示了TSC1基因敲除对小鼠椎旁肌病发展的影响,该肌病具有少肌症特征。TSC1基因敲除小鼠是目前研究少肌症对小鼠脊柱病理影响的最佳模型。TSC1基因敲除小鼠早在9个月时就出现椎旁肌病,随后出现椎间盘退变和椎间盘楔变。接着在12个月时出现脊柱后凸,同时由于骨重塑导致椎间盘高度降低和椎体楔形变。在我们的研究中未发现与年龄相关的骨质流失,提示骨质疏松和肌病引起的椎体楔变可能是两个独立的过程。
这是第一项对椎旁肌病对椎间盘退变、脊柱后凸和椎体变化的早期和晚期后果提供关键见解的研究。有了这一新认识,可以开展未来研究来评估脊柱退变的治疗方法,以制定对时间敏感的干预措施。