J Am Dent Assoc. 2022 Jan;153(1):23-30. doi: 10.1016/j.adaj.2021.07.001. Epub 2021 Oct 20.
The aim of the authors was to evaluate prescription patterns for bite-wing and panoramic radiographs (PRs) for pediatric and adolescent dental patients after the implementation of the most recent guidelines from the American Dental Association and US Food and Drug Administration.
The authors accessed paid insurance claims data for all 50 states from January 1, 2013, through June 30, 2019, for patients 18 years and younger and extracted a 5% random sample population. The authors performed statistical analyses to evaluate various imaging metrics for pediatric dentists (PDs) and general practitioners (GPs).
A total of 2,123,735 bite-wing images were ordered during 4,734,249 office visits. The average (standard deviation [SD]) time interval between bite-wing examinations ordered by GPs was 13.9 (7.4) months, and for PDs the average (SD) was 13.0 (6.7) months (P < .0001). When divided by age group, 3.5% of all bite-wings were obtained from patients aged 0 through 4 years. For PRs, the authors included 286,824 images in this study. The average (SD) time interval between PRs ordered for the same patient was 3.4 (1.3) years for PDs and 3.3 (1.4) years for GPs. One percent of all PRs were ordered for patients aged 0 through 4 years, with 403 images attributed to PDs and 2,348 to GPs.
PDs were more likely to comply with the guidelines on radiograph prescriptions for pediatric and adolescent patients than GPs.
Inclusion of patient caries risk with insurance claims data could be considered for more appropriate administration of dental radiography. Future guidelines should be developed to include more explicit recommendations for prescribing PRs.
作者旨在评估在遵循美国牙科协会和美国食品药品监督管理局最近发布的指南后,儿科和青少年牙科患者的拍摄根尖片和全景片(PR)的处方模式。
作者从 2013 年 1 月 1 日至 2019 年 6 月 30 日,获取了全美 50 个州的付费保险理赔数据,涵盖了 18 岁及以下的患者,并提取了一个 5%的随机抽样人群。作者进行了统计分析,以评估儿科牙医(PD)和全科医生(GP)的各种影像学指标。
在 4734249 次就诊中,共开出了 2123735 张根尖片。GP 每次就诊之间平均(标准差 [SD])时间间隔为 13.9(7.4)个月,而 PD 为 13.0(6.7)个月(P<0.0001)。按年龄组划分,3.5%的根尖片来自 0 至 4 岁的患者。在本研究中,作者纳入了 286824 张 PR 图像。对于同一位患者,PD 平均(SD)时间间隔为 3.4(1.3)年,GP 为 3.3(1.4)年。0 至 4 岁患者中,有 1%的患者接受了 PR 检查,其中 403 张图像由 PD 开出,2348 张由 GP 开出。
PD 比 GP 更有可能遵守针对儿科和青少年患者的放射检查处方指南。
将患者龋齿风险纳入保险理赔数据,有助于更合理地管理牙科放射检查。未来的指南应制定更明确的 PR 处方建议。